eh
well at first the story was good.. but then i realized that if robots dont have emotion then they dont have a conscious so they wouldnt be aware that they are missing anything emotional
nice flash tho
Reviews for "Tinman"
BlackmarketKraig responds:
That's probably true, but who knows what robot's that can walk around and build stuff of their own accord might be like...
Thanks for reviewing! :)
Thumbs Down
No humor.
No violence.
No interactivity.
Just some person's feeble attempt at "touching" someone.
What I am trying to say is...
I don't like Dashboard Confessional, ergo I don't like this flash movie.
Thanks anyways.
BlackmarketKraig responds:
No, there is no violence, no humor and no interactivity. But lacking any or all of those things does not necessarily make for a bad flash. I mean I understand not liking this, but please offer a valid reason. Many movies in the top 50 on this site lack those things.
..and I have no idea what not liking Dashboard Confessional has to do with anything. There is no Dashboard Confessional music, the music it does have sounds nothing like Dashboard Confessional. I'm afraid I don't quite follow. Unless you are using the example of Dashboard Confessional as a way of pidgeonholing anything that has to do with emotion...
Thanks for reviewing.
...
I don't really have a comment to give this besides that it is a work of art.
BlackmarketKraig responds:
Wow, thank you SO much!
<3
good
that was pretty good but if there were robots such as the one in the flash then they would have AI...they wouldn't be programmed to want to have fealings like humans because thats whats wrong with humanity...if someone fucks over somebody else hate comes in and makes the person kill the other..so robots would be programmed not to have human emotions..anyways you did a good job
BlackmarketKraig responds:
You might be right, emotion creates a lot of problems in the world. But a sterile world free of passion, joy and sorrow would be a pretty uninteresting place to live, I imagine.
Not bad. Styalized but missing the message.
One thing I can point out for when you do your next flash movie: The robot's arms were swinging the wrong way. When the leg goes back, the arm goes forward -- like the way people walk, otherwise it looks strange.
And I did get the impression of lonliness from the movie. But I don't think it quite conveys what your description is trying to illustrate.
The quality is good though. This should set the bar for new animators. Anything below this standard is people dicking around (who should be impaled). And your audio is the best quality I've ever heard.
BlackmarketKraig responds:
Yeah, about the arms. Heh, I knew something was wrong with the way he was walking but I couldn't put my finger on it until another reviewer pointed it out.
Thanks for the complements about the quality of the animation.
And yeah, I really dislike bad audio quality, I try to have it optimized but when you cut down the bitrate (is that the right word?) too much you lose quite a lot.