00:00
00:00
Newgrounds Background Image Theme

b0sszkr1 just joined the crew!

We need you on the team, too.

Support Newgrounds and get tons of perks for just $2.99!

Create a Free Account and then..

Become a Supporter!

Reviews for "Scenic (Piano)"

Tell me the story...

It started off great, but then it kind've got repetitive until 1:30 where it felt like a lot of momentum started to build. The melody is awesome by itself, but it wouldn't hurt to change the melody while keeping the same rhythm and general idea. Also, the song kept at the same pitch keeps the song a little stale, but maybe you were looking for a more stable melody. I think this song would sound a lot better if you reached a few high notes for a stronger dramatic effect (since your with someone close), or from the low transition at 1:30 build it up to a higher octave (cause that is what I was anticipating), or maybe even add some pedal or an ambient effect. It's not bad to keep it level as it is, because then it would be a well written peaceful background. It felt like the song was supporting the moment rather than describing the moment that one would feel. Like supporting the story while it is being told rather than telling the story itself. These are just opinions though. I look at what people are trying to create and I try to situate myself in the author's scenario and tell them if "I'm there." I wasn't quiet there for this one, but it turned out to be a great piece anyways. Hope some of this will help. Keep up the good work. (Definitely beats many other songs I've heard on new grounds, I only rate the ones I think have potential or are already the best I think they can be) =)

midimachine responds:

I think the repetitiveness is because I was originally planning to have vocals on this but decided against it. Also, I come from the electronica school of thought where you can get away with a lot more repetition. Not that it's an excuse because I hate when artists try and defend themselves against **constructive** criticism.

You're absolutely right though. I think I get too used to playing and writing *backing* music so when I go for something that's meant to take the lead it sounds like backing music anyway. Thanks a lot for the review and kind words :D

nice..

very nice song doode
try adding a chello in there, r not cos this is already a good tune...
keep it up man

midimachine responds:

Cello would be nice but I'd have to change the piano sound to something brighter because at the moment the two sounds would probably clash i think...

Thanks for the review!