Many of the characters are out of... character, the voice acting is close to horrible and almost nothing makes any sense. I do take into account that this was made eight years ago, but I don't think it would've made any more sense then than it does now.
I like the concept, though, and some of the ideas were really original. Such as Sephiroth's little musical number. (Barret shouldn't be able to play the drums since he doesn't have a right arm, though.)
I like random things, but this went a bit too far, some things seemed unnecessary and just served to further confuse me.
All in all, it was ok. I didn't dislike it.