Reviews for NG Time Trial Challenge B

[Luis]

two great extremes

I really liked both works, this is the first time I am seeing it. Both very different in every sense of the word and thats really all this ng time trial thing is about. Variety and creativity and stuff.. good job both of u.

Pinnicle- I like your sense of humor, your characters really benefit greatly from the voice acting u provide. The crude style and handling really has evolved and turned into a calling card.
keep it up.

Alanthebox- great stuff as usual, love your line work. great idea, its so refreshing to see someone take the non humor approach. gj

[BearFrog]

Another BearFrog Review

Okay, what's with all the Pinnicle dissing? I myself thought that his was better. The leaves thing was pretty boring to me. I have an artistic and romantic side but that wasn't too interesting. Plus the white around the leaves was annoying. However, I thought it was good. Just a little dry. Rocky's was funny and is the perfect example of a quality movie you'd find on newgrounds. "You're gonna go to hell!" However, the movement in the scene where Rocky entered seemed sloppy, but it's probably just my computer.

So let me give you my overall scores for the both of them:
Pinnicle's: Great
AlantheBox's : Good

[The-Prof]

I'd say Alan's was the better.

I didn't really feel Pinnicle's meant anything to be honest, it was a little boring :S

But Alan's was done really well, I loved the style of graphics, and the way it was set out. (Which was quite great really).

You don't except something like that to be a love story, and it's like a "suprise ending" if you will.. To find it's actually about the leaves, which does make sense, if you look back on it.

Pinncales was cool and all, Well.I didn't really like it but I couldn't of done neary as good.

Great work Alan :)

[NintendoMadness]

Woot... Woot

I liked this one alot especially the Fall on. Ther were no voices but you could tell that those two leaves were friends.

[emokitten21]

random but wicked good

if u had given this more of a story or a nice loud song with lyrics into this i think it would have been better. but omfg you are wicked good at drawing!! loved the graphics. loved the guitar strumming in the background. good job :]