At 9/10/06 06:16 PM, Doodle wrote:
gfoxcook, are you a Moderator or something??
Of course not. Whatever would have given you that impression?
At 9/10/06 06:22 PM, FatherTime89 wrote:
At 9/10/06 06:14 PM, gfoxcook wrote:
Please read the posts by myself and ASSMAN on pages 27 and 28.
(snip)
What i still don't get is why u are doing this, I don't have the time to go through all 27 pages of this thread (yes I know this is ironic considering my username), but still I have read some of the posts you suggested and I'm still confused,
Well thank you for at least TRYING, FatherTime. That's more than I can say for a lot of the people whose posts I've read in this topic, and I haven't even read 25% of it.
Since you're trying, I'll try to explain it even better, kay? Here we go:
is this for the new site change that Tom has been hinting about for months?
Most likely.
And it's just generally good username practice, as he mentioned by saying "lots of other sites don't allow these characters in usernames." The reasons for which he left up to our imagination, but it doesn't take much to guess a few of those reasons. They include a lot of technical reasons to make names mostly just letters and numbers (never a bad idea, IMO), not include spaces, and not include a LOT of symbols on our keyboards. Just because you can type something in a post doesn't mean you should be able to have it in your username.
Is it just to look better or will this solve some unknown problem that should've come and bit the admins in the but a long time ago?
I doubt there were really any unknown problems with the site as it was and usernames that have dashes or underscores. This is to solve problems that those characters WILL create once the new site design is released. It makes perfect logical sense that this change to username rules is for the BACKEND of the site (the structure, the foundation, the skeleton, the programming, the coding, whatever you want to call it), not the FRONTEND (the face, the look, the outward appearance, the aesthetics, the superficial cosmetics) of the site.
IOW, this isn't just "to look better," no.
This is so the site can move forward and so Tom and the other admins can implement the awesome design changes they've been wanting to apply to NG without little tickytack technical details getting in the way.
If all of us having simpler, cleaner-looking, but more restrictive and less free usernames means the owner and admins of this site can have a ton more freedom to experiment and improve the site... aren't you all for it?
I'm no programmer, I know a little bit of Html but that's it so will you please explain to me why this is done unless it's all a big secret.
I'm not a programmer either, but if you know some html and you know anything about the web, you should know that if you have a username that's in a URL, say, and the site this username is from allows SPACES (the dreaded space!! OH NOE!) in usernames, then when you try to go to a site like that... say...
http://www.somesite.com/Father Time/index.html
it ain't gonna work! Spaces aren't allowed in web addresses. This is why they're converted to %20 or whatever, if you've ever seen %20s all over the place, that's the reason why.
Similarly, _s or -s might have some technical and practical use in a URL or code, and that would be a reason not to allow them in usernames. Imagine there is a function called "doshit," okay? Here's an example:
doshit(gfoxcook,4,6)
doshit(Father_Time,4,6)
Ooops, the second one doesn't work because of the underscore, the function thinks Father and Time are two different thingies, so it bugs out...
doshit("Father_Time",4,6)
Now maybe putting it all in quotes like that works, but it's a pain in the ass. Why put "s when usernames like gfoxcook and any other single words... = simplicity, = no bugs, = no problems.
I hope this makes it a bit more understandable. This is all just conjecture on my part, but I would wager it bears some resemblance to the truth of the reasons behind this change. I wasn't surprised at all when I heard about this move away from symbols in our usernames, let's just say.