I can say with confidence that the strangest meal I've ever had would be grilled Burmese python. Actually tasted a bit like a chewy version of something between chicken and duck. They're apparently an invasive species in Florida. People got them as exotic pets and they got out and had a population explosion in the Everglades. There's tons of pictures of them competing with, and even eating (and as a result killing themselves) alligators. Apparently they have a "kill on sight" notice, so eating them is just beneficial to the surrounding ecosystem.
Second weirdest would be deep-fried minnows. Flavorless, mild fishy aftertaste. All the flavor is pretty much in whatever goes into the batter.
Both of these meals my father says someone told him are "traditional Florida meals" which is weird because I thought the traditional Florida meal was meth. (insert sound effects)
I was born ready. My eyelashes, alas, were not.