In your opinion, what's the best movie that George Lucas and/or Steven Spielberg been involved in and why?
(I highly suggest doing a movie marathon of George Lucas and Steven Spielberg films right now)
Best George Lucas/Spielberg Movie?
2,793 Views | 34 Replies
От каждого по способностям, каждому по потребностям
Indiana Jones and the Raiders of the Lost Ark.
Formerly PuddinN64 - BBS, Icon, and Portal Mod
"Your friends love you anyway" - Check out Guinea Something Good!
Hard to say which was truly his best, but I personally found A.I. Artificial Intelligence to be particularly good. Spielberg is such a good filmmaker that picking only one of his films as his best is, IMO, impossible.
For George Lucas, though, the obvious answer is Star Wars.
At 5/30/15 09:18 PM, DJ-Ri wrote:
For George Lucas, though, the obvious answer is Star Wars.
But which Star Wars movie is the best one?
At 5/30/15 09:21 PM, TheGamechanger wrote: But which Star Wars movie is the best one?
The original, IMO.
At 5/30/15 09:21 PM, TheGamechanger wrote:At 5/30/15 09:18 PM, DJ-Ri wrote:But which Star Wars movie is the best one?
For George Lucas, though, the obvious answer is Star Wars.
Empire. That was easy.
I have nothing against people who can use pot and lead a productive life. It's these sanctimonius hippies that make me wish I was a riot cop in the 60's
I guess Star Wars. The only other one I saw was Raiders of the Lost Ark and while I think it's good, I also think it's overrated.
At 5/30/15 09:28 PM, stafffighter wrote:At 5/30/15 09:21 PM, TheGamechanger wrote:Empire. That was easy.At 5/30/15 09:18 PM, DJ-Ri wrote:But which Star Wars movie is the best one?
For George Lucas, though, the obvious answer is Star Wars.
I'm not sure if this is anything to consider, but Lucas didn't direct that one, or episode six for that matter.
Isn't the idea that he didn't direct them make it not just a George Lucas movie?
Yes he wrote them, produced and edited them, but he was not a director of them.
I'm actually not sure how it works to be honest..... Is it the idea that he wrote them the main aspect of credibility?
At 5/30/15 09:35 PM, DrClay wrote:At 5/30/15 09:28 PM, stafffighter wrote:I'm not sure if this is anything to consider, but Lucas didn't direct that one, or episode six for that matter.
Empire. That was easy.
Isn't the idea that he didn't direct them make it not just a George Lucas movie?
Yes he wrote them, produced and edited them, but he was not a director of them.
I'm actually not sure how it works to be honest..... Is it the idea that he wrote them the main aspect of credibility?
The criteria of this thread was involved in. And yeah, I'd argue that writing, editing and producing count. It really bugs me that director is the only off camera person anyone considers.
I have nothing against people who can use pot and lead a productive life. It's these sanctimonius hippies that make me wish I was a riot cop in the 60's
Will the 7th Star Wars movie be the best Star Wars film of all time? Or will it crash and burn in comparison? Stay tuned for when it comes into theaters, folks!
Jurassic World better hold up to its predecessors as well! It better not end up being a big steaming pile of dinosaur poo!
George Lucas is obvious Strange Magic... LOL FUCK THAT SHIT STARWARS FTW
I wasn't aware that those two collaborated. That's pretty fucking insane!
At 5/30/15 09:05 PM, Raab wrote: Raiders of the Lost Ark
Probably this as well.
I can't point out any flaws in this film, as far as I can remember.
Pretend not to care about anything, but be bothered by everything.
You may be fast on the roads but it's no use on the track.
At 5/30/15 09:05 PM, Raab wrote: Raiders of the Lost Ark
Seconded.
For George Lucas, it would of course be Star Wars.
You know the world's gone crazy when the best rapper's a white guy and the best golfer's a black guy - Chris Rock
empire strikes back is honestly a contender for the best movie of all time so
"Death upon death... Nothing but death in this barren land. Who can we pray to? There are only demons and fiends here."
~The Journal of a Man Who Wandered into Another World
At 6/1/15 12:44 PM, mysticvortex13 wrote: which one? i liked a new hope better than the other two in the original trilogy.. as to the new three.. probably revenge of the sith.
I actually heard the original Star Wars was the only one that he actually personally directed. Overall for any Star Wars movie. You're probably going to hate me for this, but I thought "Return Of The Jedi" was the best.
You know the world's gone crazy when the best rapper's a white guy and the best golfer's a black guy - Chris Rock
If we're only picking from what they've directed, I guess either Raiders or the Last Crusade for Spielberg and a New Hope for Lucas, but Empire was the best Star Wars movie.
At 6/6/15 10:13 AM, mysticvortex13 wrote:At 6/6/15 10:08 AM, Ericho wrote:I actually heard the original Star Wars was the only one that he actually personally directed. Overall for any Star Wars movie. You're probably going to hate me for this, but I thought "Return Of The Jedi" was the best.nah.. i dont hate you as long as you dont think the clone wars movie nor the force awakens were the best. those sucked.
The Force Awakens isn't coming out until Winter.
I don't know, but the 14th makes masterpieces
Sadly I don't remember watching the first 3 Indiana Jones movies, I know I saw the second and third at some point but forgot almost all of them and I think I never saw the first one. I should probably make sure to watch those.
I probably have seen many I loved which I didn't recall being theres, so I'm going to go with Return of the Jedi. I know people say it is not as good as Empire Strikes Back, but when I saw it as a child I fucking loved the action it was awesome.
I also watched it on the first re-release boxset on VHS. I never saw the "original unedited" ones, and I loved them! They didn't fuck them up as much as people claim they did on that first re-release the changes were solid. Sure Han Solo shooting first and all that jazz, but I never even noticed he did that as a child all I remembered was the fact he shot the guy dead under the table, even when it was re-released as I saw it I didn't see the shot since I wasn't paying attention to it. Han Solo totally shot first since that was where my attention was set.
Spielberg directed A.I: Artificial Intelligence which I found underrated. I can't get enough of E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial because I grew up watching.
Overall, his best is probably Close Encounters of the Third Kind. It's breathtaking.
Skype: the_sleuth
Jaws is a perfect film.
As in, you could not make a better film about a big shark eating people.
So Jaws.
At 6/6/15 04:38 PM, TheMaster wrote: Jaws is a perfect film.
As in, you could not make a better film about a big shark eating people.
So Jaws.
I also never saw that film...I really should catch up on films I must have only seen less than a hundred over my life.
Star Wars The Empire Strikes Back, although Gary Kurtz contributed more than Lucas.
Gonna have to say Raiders of the Lost Ark.
At 6/6/15 11:07 PM, CommunistSock wrote: star wars
Which episode?
At 6/6/15 11:14 PM, TheGamechanger wrote:At 6/6/15 11:07 PM, CommunistSock wrote: star warsWhich episode?
When someone just calls a single movie Star Wars, I think it's safe to guess that they mean A New Hope. Unless CommunistSock means the entire series...?
At 6/6/15 11:16 PM, someaveragechap wrote:Which episode?
111 episode revenge of the sith 2005
my next choice wud be the 4th episode
