At 12/24/11 05:09 PM, Coop wrote:
Sorry, are we talking about American or Libyan troops here? Oh, it was the Libyans, because you can afford tons and tons of ammunition, because let's face it, you waste more than most. Hell, how much did you waste in shooting British troops in Afghanistan? During the conflict, you caused more British caualties than we sustained from the Taliban.
Before we mouth off about whose military can't shoot why don't we examine the empirical evidence?
Incidents of UK on UK Friendly Fire Incidents in Afghanistan -
1) In Sangin Province, a RAF Harrier mistakenly strafed British troops missing the enemy by 200 metres during a firefight with the Taliban in August 20, 2006. This angered British Major James Loden of 3 PARA, who called the RAF, "Completely incompetent and utterly, utterly useless in protecting ground troops in Afghanistan". British paratroopers even said that they rather prefer US air-support over the RAF.
No injuries or deaths
2) Lance Corporal Matthew Ford, from Zulu Company of 45 Commando Royal Marines, died after receiving a gunshot wound in Afghanistan on January 15, 2007, which was later found to be due to friendly fire. The final inquest ruled he died from NATO rounds from a fellow Royal Marine's machine gun. The report added there was no "negligence" by the other Marine, who had made a "momentary error of judgment".
One Death
3) On July 9, 2008, nine British soldiers from the 2nd Battalion, The Parachute Regiment were injured after being fired upon by British Army Apache helicopter while on patrol in Afghanistan.
Nine Injuries
4) Captain Tom Sawyer, aged 26, 29 Commando Regiment Royal Artillery, and Corporal Danny Winter, aged 28, Zulu Company 45 Commando Royal Marines, were killed by an explosion on 14 January 2009. Both men were taking part in a joint operation with a Danish Battle Group and the Afghan National Army in a location north east of Gereshk in central Helmand Province. The MoD subsequently confirmed that two men died from friendly fire when they were hit in error by a Javelin anti-tank missile from British troops.
Two Deaths
5) A British Military Police officer was shot dead by a fellow British soldier while on patrol. It was reported that no charges are to be brought against a British army sniper who killed a British Military Policeman because he was allowed to open fire if he believed that his life was in danger.
One death
6) Sapper Mark Antony Smith, age 26, of the 36 Engineer Regiment, Royal Engineers, was killed by a smoke shell fired upon by British troops in Sangin Province, Afghanistan. The MoD is investigating his death and said a smoke shell, designed to provide cover for soldiers working on the ground, may have fallen short of its intended target.
One Death
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friendly_fi re#War_in_Afghanistan
Now, on the other hand...
US on UK Friendly Fire Incidents in Afghanistan.
1) On 5 December 2006, an F/A-18C on a Close Air Support mission in Helmand Province, Afghanistan, mistakenly attacked a trench where British Royal Marines were dug-in during a 10-hour battle with Taliban fighters, killing one Royal Marine
One Death
2) 5 December 2006: British Marine Pte. Jonathan Wigley's death was caused by gunfire from a U.S. F-18 aircraft.
One Death
3) July 2007: British Guardsman Matthew Lyne-Pirkis, of the Grenadier Guards, was wounded along with three other allied soldiers of the Afghan National Army after being hit by gunfire from a U.S. Apache helicopter gunship.
Four injuries
4) August 23, 2007: A USAF F-15 called in to support British ground forces in Afghanistan dropped a bomb on those forces. Three privates of the 1st Battalion, the Royal Anglian Regiment, were killed and two others were severely injured. It was later revealed that the British forward air controller who called in the strike had not been issued a noise-cancelling headset, and while he supplied the correct target co-ordinates, in the confusion and stress of the battle incorrectly confirmed one wrong digit mistakenly repeated by the pilot, and the bomb landed on the British position 1000 metres away from the enemy. The coroner at the soldiers' inquest stated that the incident was due to "flawed application of procedures" rather than individual errors or "recklessness".
The above is a tough one to call. The British air controller did give faulty coordinates, but technology had failed in this case. I only included it for the sake of completion.
5) Of two helicopters called in to support operations by the British Grenadier Guards and Afghan National Army forces in Helmand, the British Westland WAH-64 Apache engaged enemy forces, while the accompanying American AH-64D Apache opened fire on the Grenadiers and Afghan troops.
No injuries or deaths.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S ._friendly-fire_incidents_since_1945_wit h_British_victims
So, unless I made a clerical error then the score so far is..........
British personnel killed and/or injured by British: Five deaths, nine injuries.
British personnel killed and/or injured by Americans: two deaths, four injuries.