At 3/5/09 07:59 PM, Kor-Rune wrote:
Well, it sounds far more organic, and to me, after awhile, completely digital vst guitars start to sound cold and harsh, no matter how much midtone you cram on there.
Fair enough. I however, am quite partial to the sound of a properly implemented Slayer patch. I think if you actually open up your mind to something new, instead of depending on what you already know and trust, you can do amazing things.
Sometimes something so human has flow, of notes ever so slightly off time, and the natural human velocity has power and kinetic feel to the music. If music was all completely square and perfect without dynamics, it would become boring and routine. Imperfections aren't necessarily flaws.
And the exact same can be held for the opposite. There are numerous styles of music where dynamics is not the main point of attention. And yes, most guitar based music is dynamic, but I've never read the rule book that says music HAS to be dynamic. If everyone continues to abide by their silly little rules, nothing will ever change. Also, I think if people focused more on writing a good melody and rhythm, dynamics would take a back seat.
Me? Nah. But that is irrelevant, and you just seem to enjoy attacking people. Please be a nicer person so you can contribute to a healthy discussion. :(
All I see in this thread is unnecessary venom and animosity towards the use of a VST, so I thought I'd join in on the fun.
Thing is, most people aren't bashing the concept of electronic vst guitars, but how bad they sound. Drums are a far more consistant instrument, and can be replicated easily(even with actual recorded drum hits at multiple velocities), so it can sound like a natural acoustic drumset if done right. Even then, the slight human rolls and kinetics of a drum kit still aren't present, but can be very close.
Electronic VST guitars don't sound bad, they sound different.
And sure, a synthetic drumset CAN sound like a natural acoustic drumset when done right, but alot of the "real" guitarists on NG seem to make a bit of an oversight in that area. What's the point of potential, if people aren't even using it?
I suppose then that you can argue that the Drumkit From Hell plugin is a bit pricey, but then that brings us full circle back to an often argued about facet of the virtual guitarist. A few people who use Slayer say that they can't afford a guitar, and then I see them get torn to shreds about how a guitar isn't very expensive! Well, I can tell you, a guitar and a basic recording interface costs a bit more than EZDrummer, for instance.
And even then, I've heard quite a few tracks using just the built in loops.
Look, I don't even care about that. Music is music. It's a personal thing, and every song has it's place. But all the hypocrisy and ignorance in this thread cannot go unchecked. It saddens me to see so many jaded people ripping into a small portion of our community for what is essentially no reason.