Reviews for Dark Reflection

[SketchMichaels]

Pros and cons...

...while I think you have a nice style, it was kind of jarbled. I know your intentions, but I don't think you pulled it off well. The main problem I have is that there is no closure; you have this girl crying, yada yada, and there's blood everywhere, but there is no definitive point. Did she witness a murder? Did she kill someone? Et cetera... whenever one tries to do a psychological piece, it's always nice to let the audience know why, adds to the intensity. Other than that, it was nicely done.

p.s. You shouldn't be a dick to Tijo221 just because he expressed his opinion. Not everyone who watches your stuff is going to be a fan; you have to take the good with the bad.

n8x responds:

first of all, i was joking in my response to tijo, although an unintelligent review deserves an unintelligent response. your comment has a point, and i understand what you're saying about closure. it was however an experimental peice, and wasn't meant to have any story or definite point, only to convey some emotion and practice flash. doesn't make it any better in that respect, but it is what it is.

[Blaklyon]

Kudos for the music

the music fitted well with what was going on....if, you could tell what was going on.... what was wrong with that girl? suicidal thoughts? good job..

[Keredan]

Intresting.

I didn't really understand, but I thought it was ok.

[amplified22]

Nice

A little girls decent into anger. I liked it. Things where happening all around her...she's losing her mind, felt like she way free falling...
The music went fantasic with the animation, however i thought the whole thing needed a little bit more depth.

[brainmalfunction]

pretty kewl

at first it didnt really made sense and it kinda seemed corny, coz it was like, out of the blue some silly thing happens and it becomes like a suppose-to-be-disturbing kind of dream. the animation was alright, but i think it would have been better if the coloring was finer and not so scattered, erm..messy. overall, it was pretty good especially the last part, her breathing was what made it really nice, i could just imagine myself there and id really freak out a little.. and have prolly tears in my eyes even. you can do better, the plot's awesome, you jsut need to work on it a little more. :)