To be honest...
Not as good as Rose, the main fast melo is a 4 bars tune that just keeps repeating itself and it gets really annoying, though its really well made but it still it doesnt seem you put the same effort...
The violin/cello part was actually (for my taste) better that Rose's and the tempo change at the end of the song was just breathtaking!
I just hope your not angry or something about the nine, I just think you put more effort into Rose ^^
Im still gonna fav this one! ^.~
Keep it up idol! ;P