I feel like you took the original song and just added a load of sound effects over it. I like the thought and concept, yet I don't like how you remixed it. Remixing can be something really creative, and this is just not a reflection of that.
The second half does seem better at a remix but the second drop is just more sound effects slapped on to the original tune. Nice try, but no cigar.
I know this remix has received immense support from its listeners, and I respect their opinions. I just can't see why this remix is seen as so good.
You even said that you threw it around a bit, but it sounds like you threw it all in a jug, mixed it, emptied it and uploaded it. Thanks for your patience.