I much preferred the first chapter (which I consider to be one of my favorite games of all time). I felt like some of the puzzles in this second chapter weren't quite as well thought-out. It irked me that I had no idea how to answer the "3 question" puzzle, and that I couldn't reference an inventory item to help me solve the puzzle (so I basically had to wildly guess). Furthermore, and this is a matter of taste, I didn't like how there was so much religious undertone in the game. Basically, the game was a different kind of creepy compared to the first chapter, and it wasn't to my taste.
Of course, excellent production value and music.