Nice music, smooth graphics, and a good choice of sound effects, but I agree with the others, the major error to this game, is it needs more choices!
I've been thinking of some ideas. Prehaps you could select a weapon, shield, maybe accesories such as necklaces etc. Also physical changes such as eye colour, skin colour, and hair style/colour. Also if you could give them horses, and edit the horses apearence in similair ways, that would very great, and would definantly get a 5-star from me.
Oh, also, a colour selector for the armour would be nice. A specific armour I would like to see is a roman-style chest-plate, and possibly knights armour.
Overall, a good game, just needs more complex options.