Reviews for Sonic vs Natsu

[00ND00]

good:
-animation was fluid
-the fight had some good variety

bad
-the "badass" black face thing is just bad in general
- you took a character whose progression of power level is based on bullshit. lost a fight? holy flame aura , lost another fight? secret technique everyone knows of but was never mentioned before , enemy way too strong and you already lost against him and have no power? just eat somebody's power (even though it was stated that he should only be able to eat flames) and kick the guy's arse who almost killed your master

In conclusion:
-Animation excellent
-personal choices (fight, elements of comic relief, etc) good in general
-character choice : meh; nobody likes a Mary Sue; atleast let him fight another Mary Sue. Although you could have probably just thrown Super mode and Chaos control at Sonics face and the result might have been a little more interesting

[SeraphimofFire]

Most of the problems are in the first half. The music sets a pace that's a bit too frenetic right off the bat. Consider some sort of lead-in or fade. Also I found the action a little hard to follow at some points. Might want to add in a couple of short "pauses for breath" to let people take in the epicness they've just seen.

Overall, for something that started as a test, I think this is pretty decent. Nothing revolutionary, but I don't want my 30 seconds back either. Few tweaks and this could be a really solid short sequence.

SquirrelKidd responds:

Thanks a lot for this feedback, really helps! :D

[Kreepo]

look, the video is cool but seriosly you forgot abbout super sonic.... i mean nazo won couse sonic didnt go super sonic.... super sonic is literaly imortal and im not saying this couse i like sonic most but becouse he only didnt put super sonic there so nazo wold win...

my rating 3... if it had super sonic... even if sonic wold lose... 4 couse its to short...

[motork]

Meh, the animation is good and all, but the whole fight is mainly one sided, and im sorry but sonic would win in my opinion, and to be honest i never even hear of natsu, so yea sorry. Work on the whole fighting sequence and im sure you'll go far.

[aknig01]

ive seen fairy tail but sonic would still win he has destroyed intire armys and beaten people who eat galaxys and in the comics it said "sonic running at full speed causes the earth to shake in super sonic mode" good video anyways