Hm...
I'm going to put this right in the middle. I think the idea was really cute, and I like the fact that you can still draw outside the lines of the weapons/hats/etc and be unique with your creations.
However, the gameplay gets a little choppy. The music in the background looping is hard to deal with (I muted it after 5 or 10 minutes). While seeing your objects in action was fun... the controls were weird and uncomfortable. Maybe I was the only one with this problem, but my melee weapon wouldn't work period with the controls, and the throwing weapon only worked half of the time.
Still, very creative. I love the look of the levels (involving hands and other unrelated things to make platforms and such), and I give you props for thinking of something different.