I know you said not to dog you for making a game that is like Doodle God, and if that's all you had done, I wouldn't. But this IS Doodle God. I would have loved if you had taken Doodle God aspects, and maybe made some more of the combinations make sense (like a new combination to make ice instead of just stealing Doodle God's). It's like you had Doodle God open in another tab while you made this one. Might as well call it, "Doodle God: Amateur Game Programmer on a Budget". I mean, for real? It was cool, but make it your own! I felt like I was playing Doodle God back in 1999. I just wasn't as impressed as I thought I was going to be. Sorry. It was a good idea, you just need to change some more stuff and make it more your own. You do that, and I would love to see it.
Reviews for "Elementcyclopaedia"
There are many things I can say about this comment, not negative things either, so I will just list them I guess.
1. I wouldn't really call my game Doodle God, that would be a compliment. Also, Doodle God's combinations make more sense than mine!
2. Your element combination example is actually a bad one, as that is one of the few I didn't borrow. (Or at least, didn't mean to.)
3. This game was not made for the purpose of having a good and original game. I had been playing a lot of Doodle God and was bored, so I decided to make a game, because why not. Also, it was made in about a week-ish. I only uploaded it here because everything else I had on here was bad! (And still is)
4. When I go back and play this game, I do not find any minute of it enjoyable. I was going to make a much better 'sequel' (if you can even call it that) but I guess I don't have the inspiration to make a game of this style. (Also that one would have more than one combination for elements because that was a terrible idea :I)
I agree with most of what you said (except the budget thing. no money was spent anywhere in the development of this game) and whilst I am saddened by the existence of this game, it is all I have on the internet to show for myself. (Which makes me feel even worse!)
I wish I could just finish the game I've been working on for 5 years and have remade 4 times. :c
Like Doodle god, but MORE ILLOGICAL!