Reviews for The Many Kirbys Collab

[RecorderEvans]

Big hit and miss session.

When I started watching it, I was having a ball. I was laughing, pointing at the screen screaming, "DID THAT REALLY HAPPEN!?" All the while enjoying myself. When it came to the middle sections, I lost all interest. It felt like the middle cartoons were just trying too hard to be funny and the delivery fell flat. But once the flash came to the end stretch, it picked back up again. I was again laughing and having a good time.

The point I am trying to make of this: It was a huge hit and miss session. When the skit hit the mark, it hit good. It was witty, clever, funny, and everything was smooth. When it missed, oh man did it miss by a mile! I do appreciate the skip feature because otherwise I'd be docking points left and right. The bad skits were bland, the voice acting was lame, and the jokes made me cringe in disappointment.

It's a mixed bag. But because of the skip feature and the good skits, it deserves the pass. It's just unfortunate that this didn't live up to the full potential it had.

FlashfireEX responds:

Fair enough.

[Andropinus]

one at a time

Whenever i watch a collab i know there will be a mix of qualities. This makes them hard to review as a whole so i will break it up and deal with them one at a time.

UFO- I had trouble understanding this one, Kirby is a UFO? No explanation why all this was happening, art looked like it took 2 mins in MS paint. 3/10

Cutter- Kirby was obvioussly feeling like a retard this morning as he is wearing a retard hat and his retard face. Would have been much funnier if he had choked on the banana. Graphics were not bad. 3/10

Cook- This one was good. The salesman was kirby how this is a refrence to kirby culture im not sure, however it did make me smile. 7/10

Paint- Ahh good old sprite animation, the humour was nice. 8/10

Drill- Yet another snuff animation. Art was nice, except for the actual kill, cutting a wedge out of him looked weird. 6/10

Ice- Ok kirby eats stuff and gain powers from it, like he allways has. Nothing original in terms of story. Nice animation 7/10

Sword- Poor art and the ending felt a little disjointed. 5/10

Animal- Nice art but i still dont understand what was going on, whats with the line at the end? Sorry i just dont get it 5/10

Fire- Cute story, decent art. Not a lot else to say really. 7/10

Freeze- This is the worst of the lot. Art was crap. Hate, swearing and abuse is not a substitute for humour. 1/10

Spaghetti- The best of the lot. Nice sprite work, great story. This is the only one of this lot that actually made me laugh. 9/10

Ninja- Great animation. It had no story but i guess you did not intend it to have one. Nice tempo and action shots. 8/10

So if i average these scores i get 5.75. So i will give this a 6

FlashfireEX responds:

Thanks for taking the time to review these but I don't get where you're coming from with my freeze kirby part. I don't get where you got hate from, it's about the fact that Kirby eats enemies and in the skit tried to be friendly with them. I'm happy you liked my paint skit though and I'm glad someone finally praised the spaghetti skit.

[JarekFIRE]

Not bad...

But have some class. For pure quality of the work, it was pretty funny at times, and smooth, but seriously, you can take criticism a little better. I know it took a lot of effort to make this, but there's just no need to blast someone for their opinion. Some maturity on it would be nice to see.

FlashfireEX responds:

I don't think I blast people for their opinion. I might make a comment or two if what the person is saying is either biased or hateful but I take any other criticism unless it's inaccurate.

[alt1tab]

it was ok

most of the jokes were "ok" and the animation overall was "ok." mediocre at best.

[Broken-Wavelength]

Ehh...

Can't really say I found this enjoyable. This whole thing felt really sub-par in terms in humor, and a lot of the jokes didn't really seem to make fun of the Kirby franchise. A lot of the jokes could've been used for about pretty much any franchise. (For example, the Sword short could've also been used to make fun of Zelda or King Arthur, and don't even get me started on the Cook short) I will admit, though, some of the skits did have animation that was kinda nice (especially the Ninja short), but it's also not really the best I've seen either. I will agree that it was an improvement over the first collab, though.

FlashfireEX responds:

Fair enough. Thanks for the review.