Great aesthetic appeal
However I think the plot was lacking. I liked it, and tried to get into the plot more, but parts of it just seemed cliche and the ending left a lot to be desired. Other than that the music and visuals were stunning, so good overall (especially for only being done in 18 days) but I think if you had had more time to work on the plot and hadn't had to worry about contest deadlines this could have been truly spectacular. Nonetheless, I liked it.
Win
Tarboy killer. Great job. Did the robot thing well.
Great visual
Since the visual and audible experience was amazing, I had no issues there. The voice acting was great, the sound effects top notch. The writing of the story was a little bumpy. Most of writing a story is a process of revealing information. I liked how you chose to not reveal the item that was passed down until the end. Maybe that item could be better related to the story, or made more clear if it was related. Maybe something related to One Eye's past. Since the story was engaging up until the end, it was a little let down, but that's a compliment to the rest of it, which was together.
good
pathetic ending though. Although I do feel like you have a lot building for a sequel however. And P.S. im with you Deharke. Tarboy was much better.
A great movie
This was a great movie, but in full honesty the ending was disappointing.
With a story behind it, characters that were pretty cool and the animation that was beautiful, the ending that was put in was just... lacking.
Try to think of an ending that would be more epic instead of... something cheap.
And also, contrary to what MorkiaRed says, I feel Tarboy had a more completely story and was ultimately better.