Reviews for The Kirby Collab

[KirbyfanNeox]

How to do a constructive criticism w/o bias?

After all, I LOVE the Kirby series.
Hmm...
Well, first off, I'd like to say that Gustavos managed to make Kirby's Epic Yarn look stupid. A lot of the jokes were unecpected (like Kirby's Shoop da Whoop in Supersonic64's first segment, Waddle Dee's pulling out a gun and shooting the club guy in Chingmongna's segment, Kirby's copying the other Kirby (the resulting paradox creates a black hole) in Supersonic64's second segment, etc.
Now, I'd like to shout out to Morph94, CantripGhost, lolmetaknight, ivanhoeintights, WooleyWorld, PhinnyCupcakes, and basically everybody who gave this a low score because it used memes or some other reason. I'll admit that several memes are overused, but I happen to find most of them funny; this goes for memes not used in the collab as well. But don't you think that when a meme is used in the right context, it becomes funny again? In addition, I didn't find any problems with art, voice acting, or basically anything these people "pointed out".
Now, about the easter eggs. I loved the first one, although I thought it didn't really belong in a Kirby collab, as it was mostly referencing Super Smash Brothers and Pokemon. I didn't find the second easter egg until I saw the hint for it in the credits. It wasn't VERY funny. The third easter egg wasn't very funny, either. Huh.
Yeah, this was pretty awesome. A lot of people don't know what they were talking about. 10/10 and 4/5.

FlashfireEX responds:

This has got to be my favorite review. Honestly, I don't think the placement of memes was that damaging to the Collab (except maybe the rickroll) and I think they were used pretty precisely. I mean it's not like we used fart jokes. Yeah, the goal of Gustavos' part was to point out the flaws. It'll still be a good game of course. Budge's part was in fact out of place but I still think it deserved a place as an Easter Egg because it was pretty damn funny nonetheless. As for the low rated reviews, I think they're trying to compare this Collab to ones with better artists and writers. I really don't think that's what they should be doing considering this Collab doesn't even have a score of 4.00. So it probably shouldn't be criticized so heavily in my opinion.

[Leman789456123]

Pretty good

Room for improvement of course, but there always is.

My only complaint is the lack of a Pause button! D:

FlashfireEX responds:

If I put in a pause button it would wreck timed movieclips. That's the only reason I didn't put one in. Thanks!

[Lawyerman]

Decent animation but little humor

The animation all around was not that bad. However, there weren't many parts that made me laugh (only the two kirby vortex). I know I'm not an animator, but the humor could have been more than referencing to SMBZ and random internet jokes. Still, this could be the first rough draft of a great idea. If you continue, I hope it improves.

FlashfireEX responds:

The humor seems to hit other people in different ways. Thanks for the review.

[ArtehFX]

Really good comedy and animation ^^

Wow this is REALLY good and the animation is EPIC ;D plus it was hilarious xD!!!

FlashfireEX responds:

I'm glad you think so. Thanks!

[CantripGhost]

weak sauce

mostly un funny. the quality of most (all) of the art was low, as well. It sucks, because you guys could have totally nailed this collab.

FlashfireEX responds:

I thought we did, honestly. We didn't have the best art in the world but it wasn't terrible.