really great
make an animation of a stand up comedy show was esplendid
Reviews for "Old Mill Pond"
Very good idea!
I actually never saw a flash like this,
it's a pretty good idea to use a cabaret show.
I mean the story is all there, you just have to animate it.
... I really suck in making a good story so I think I'll make one of these
my self.
Very well animated and great lipsinking!!
9/10 5/5!!!
GREETZZZZ BlackEyeVision
Nice job!
This was an entertaining flash. I have never heard of this comedian, but he seems to be pretty funny, and it's a great idea to make flash animations with that audio. The animation itself was good and of course the humor was, especially the end.
Wow, you really nailed it.
McBean, I've been a fan of yours, and this latest project not only does not disappoint, it makes me like you more.
The animation was not only smooth and well done on its own, but it also lent itself superbly well to the subject matter at hand, really capturing Birbiglia's narration and style, adding to both the animation and the audio simultaneously. The scene change timing and lip syncing was all excellent.
The length of the flash was fine, and ended on a nice note. Ending where you did left enough time to make a decent length flash at ended at a departure point where the joke topic was able to conclude itself, so you didn't extend the flash beyond the logical concluding point, which is good.
I really can't see many flaws in this flash, if any. The only thing I can even pull out of my ass to whien about is that you didn't make the jokes yourself, but I really can't complain about that for two reasons: one, it was still funny, and it's meant as a sort of tribute/homage, which is the whole point, and two, your animation itself was funny, since you added your own sight gags that weren't included in the dialogue, effectively adding to the foundation of the humor.
Very nice work. I thoroughly enjoyed this, and I look forward to anything else you make in the future.
Question
Did you make the animation and put a live show soundtrack on it... if yes, Great Work!