Yeah........That's definetly NG.......
In fact I think that is one of the problems, the penis jokes are so rampant that they ruin otherwise great flashes, take "Queers of War" or the "MGS Collab", such comedic gold just standing there, and it's all about dicks?
Also concerning the screamer, I read about it ahead of time so it didn't get me, but does anyone remember when the screamer thing was so popular? So to me, it IS a representation of NG history.
This was a great collection of clips essentially summing up Newgrounds, even though there are many brilliant and meaningful flashes, the trash outweighs the art.
Also, don't be surprised about front page, it was funny and very relate able to everyone on this site, great work.
Graphics: Bad, but in a good way. There is a difference between bad artistic talent and a more "sketchy" kind of drawing style.
Sound: Great, sound clips that are common in most flashes, so again, it really relates well to the content.
Story: It's about Newgrounds
Style: This fits in very much with graphics, and it fits well because although drawn (for the most part) by you, having easily recognizable characters are important.
Overall I lenjoyed this one, it could almost pass for a collaboration project, except in a mocking way, LOVE it.
Congrats on front page, keep it up!