Reviews for Cardboard City

[shadowrabbit]

Morons,

All of them. I'm not going to force myself to use big words just to seem like some genius, i'm just going to say it straight out:

A lot of these negative reviews are full of crap.

There didn't need to be any story. It was a terrific animation, especially when you stop and think that all these animators got together, used the same kind of visual device in all these different vignettes of a city to make this animation. I think what's making a lot of people bash this animation is the fact that it all meshes together so perfectly.

You see other compilations and collabs get rave reviews, and there's absolutely no cohesiveness through the whole thing. The styles are radically different, the vignettes have no linked plots, the quality doesn't even match from one to the next. But those are okay, because, "Ur flash maed me laff, LOLOLULZ"

This animation was good. It was a lot better than many, MANY animations i've seen here. I rarely ever write reviews, but i absolutely loved this one, and can't understand how in the hell anyone could be so totally blind to the good qualities of this animation, and even rip on this collab for things that are fresh as compared to some of the other crap that gets frontpaged.

[hobolint]

eh.... hmm...

not my kinda movie, sorta boring, but since other people like it, 10/10 5/5.

[upyours123]

ok..........

this was a ackward video but its a very good video even tho the city was made of cardboard but still a good video, i rate this a 10/10

[Tebootata]

I am in love with this

You guys did a nice job of animating a city in action, and I'm especially impressed with some of the creative ways you used the cardboard texture to create your images. The music also made me feel like this was some '70's art peice and paired well with the carbord texture.
While you could argue that there isn't a story, who cares. This is more of a "day in the life" piece, meant to be observed and observed only. It's nice to see this kind of animation happening here. I really didn't expect it.
And no explosions blood or 1337 speak whatsoever... My god am I on the right website???

MorrowDays responds:

yeah, this is newgrounds, as unexpected as it may seem. everything by everyone, gotta love it! :)

you appreciated it without a story, congrats! not a lot of people can do that apparently. :P

moro

[Chibi-Wright]

That was something different.

People aren't giving this 10s because it's not like the flashes on Newgrounds.

This is artistic, and new. You guys all did a great job.