00:00
00:00
Newgrounds Background Image Theme

MiyuTheSceneGirl just joined the crew!

We need you on the team, too.

Support Newgrounds and get tons of perks for just $2.99!

Create a Free Account and then..

Become a Supporter!

Reviews for "Subordinate Droids 3"

very good

very good animation, and so on and so forth. basically everything that most people said is correct. and like most, its just not my kind of flash. you should try, after you finish with this which i hope goes well by the way, you should try making a cool action flash. experiment with really cool moves, and watch other nice action flash ones, because i would love to see a cool fight scene in your style of animation. now i know it might not be your thing, but i was just suggesting since most people here usually come here for hilarous comedy or action, oh or the exception of the really really good drama or crazy storylline like the yuma's and stuff like so.

sorbitol responds:

Thanks for the well-wishes!
I'm glad you liked the style. In the future I will be working on less cartoon-y stuff but this series is like a warm up exercise. I'm trying to get my skills up and increase the work-flow.
However, there will be more fight orientated action in the next episode (unless I have to re-write it again!) so stick around!

Thanks!

Good but out of place.

Well, the animation, art, voices etc are all really nice and it all glues together rather well, not much to say on that part. The only reason this doesn't get a 10 is because... well because this was basically a children's cartoon wheras this site is geared towards a much older audience and thus the work is neither interesting or funny for the age of the average newgrounder. So er, i dunno, try submitting it to a kids tv channel because it seems like thats the kinda place it belongs.

sorbitol responds:

"Everything, by Everyone".

Thanks for the review but I don't feel that just because something is a bit different it dosen't belong.
If that were true then why was it on the front page? Surely it would have been deleted?

Thanks anyways!

Skateboard crash joke = a start.

Okay, let me explain something. It's not enough to just put content in your cartoon. People just walking around doing stuff is boring. You need to add drama & comedy to this. As it is it's just a bunch of painfully slow scenes with painfully obvious conclusions and painfully boring dialogue.

Or to put it another way, here's what you're doing right now:
<Title Screen>
Hamish: I'm hungry.
*Hamish fixes a sandwich*
Hamish: "Great, now I can eat this sandwich!"
*sandwich falls on the floor*
Hamish: "Oh no! How will I eat my sandwich now!?"
*Hamish picks up the sandwich, blows the dust off of it.*
Hamish: (Insert really obvious pun that nobody laughs at. For good reason.)
<Ending credits>

It's boring because 100% of the things that happen in this cartoon were totally predictable. You need to mix things up a little more.

DRAMA:
*Hamish makes a sandwich and starts eating it.*
*Robot runs in* "Sir! Don't eat that sandwich!"
*Hamish looks at the half eaten sandwich and starts panicing*
Hamish: "What!? Why not! What's wrong with it!?"

Now the audience is in suspense. This is because the audience doesn't KNOW yet what's wrong with the sandwich. Like Hamish, the audience is anxious to find out what was wrong with the sandwich.

This same scene would NOT be dramatic if you already SHOWED the audience a bad guy poisoning the sandwich ahead of time. This is important. If the audience already knows there is something wrong with the sandwich, then they will EXPECT this entire scene so you mgiht as well skip it, or surprise the audience by doing the opposite of what the audience expects:

HUMOR:
*villian poisons sandwich*
*Hamish picks up the sandwich*
Robot: "Sir! Don't eat that sandwich!"
Hamish: "Oh my god! You're RIGHT! This is that crappy low-carb bread!" *throws sandwich in the trash*

You can further mix it up by making random, silly things happen. This could be humor or it could be suspenseful action, or both. Either way is fine, as long as it's UNEXPECTED!

RANDOM DRAMA:
*After the sandwich has been thrown away, the trash can starts to glow. We do NOT show the audience what's happening in the trash can, we just show that something weird is happening and cut away. Later, after the audience has forgotten about it, it'll be that much more surprising when a SANDWICH MONSTER attacks, and the audience will realize what the trash can scene meant.

RANDOM HUMOR:
If the sandwich monster wasn't random enough, maybe Hammish goes on to make his next sandwich out of two playing cards and a packet of hot sauce, because that's the only other food he could find in the house. Then when he tries to bite down on it, the packet breaks and the suace squirts out and hits the villian, who was hiding in the kitchen and maybe muttering something funny about why the poison didn't work.

INVERSION: (Do the exact opposite of what we expect)
*Villian poisons sandwich*
Robot: "NO! Don't eat it!"
*Hamish eats it*
Hamish: "Hey, that was a pretty good sandwich."
(This is funny because we were expecting him to be poisoned and he wasn't.)

After a surprise has been revealed to the audience, you have to explain why the surpsising thing happened. Either have the character wonder about it:

Robot: "Um, sir, don't humans die when they eat poison?"
Hamish: "Yeah, what's up with that?"
*They go study the crusts of the sandwich to try and figure out why*

Or have someone else figure out what's going on:

Villian: "Wait a minute... That's wasn't the poison I put in the sandwich! It was..."
DRAMA: "My new Monster Potion!"
COMEDY: "Laxative!"
RANDOM: "Coupon Spray!"
(If the sandwich was spiked with something random and silly like "coupon spray," now the audience is wondering what the heck coupon spray is. Show it in the next scene!)

The trick is to ask the audience a question, or pose a mystery, THEN answer it LATER. If you show the cause first, then the effect should be something other than what the audience expects.

You can learn more at www.tvtropes.org

Good luck mate!

sorbitol responds:

You could have just posted the web address and saved me a lot of time! :)

I do know most of this stuff already but my main objective with this episode was to introduce some new characters.
If you see episode 1 you'll see that the reason things were happening was not revealed until the end of the cartoon.
Then, in part 2, I gave them a more bona-fide adventure.
This time I was trying to follow Hamish through his normal day and bring some new characters in with events slowly building up to their conclusion.
But I'm grateful you've taken the time to recognise some potential in these cartoons and go to the trouble of braking things down in the way that you have.

I've had a little read through the site and bookmarked the page.

Thanks a lot WarpZone!

Feels like a childrens cartoon

Not my cup of tea, really. But if I were 10 I would be all over this.
Really don't take that as a bad thing. Notice I did give you a 10 afterall.
You should look to a children's network, or website. Really top notch professional work. I'm surprised your not working with one of those networks yet. (Unless you are, which would explain the quality of the animation)
I think the writing needs some work, but its got heart, and with some more clever dialog it could really soar. You should consider getting more writers to help. All that animation likely steals from any valuable script writing.

Good luck in the future!
Cheers!

sorbitol responds:

Thanks, Bluetom!

Thanks for saying that it looks professional.
No, I don't work for any T.V network but it's a great compliment!

Thanks!

Loved it.

Excellent crap and Im off to see 1 and 2 while I wait for 4.

sorbitol responds:

Thanks a lot, KAMM666! I hope you like them!