Different then what I expected but still great.
Cons -
1. Sauron's voice... bad... the other three you did it much better in.
2. Gandalf's voice kind of annoyed me a little bit
3. Animation was what I expected.
Pros -
1. Good voices for everyone else.
2. The narrating made it all the better
3. Funny throughout, one part made me laugh out loud (That's a big deal)
Ehhhs-
1. No-one seems to understand the concept of the "story book effect" it is made it look that way on purpose during The main Hobbit story.
2. In all honesty... I've noticed something about a lot of these reviews... they watch the flash, and then complain your making them again and how is is absolutely horrible and how you should've never been born etc... for the love of god, IF YOU'RE GOING TO RATE THS BAD BECAUSE LEGENDARY FROG MADE IT AND YOU HATE HIM, DON'T WATCH IT! Personally your my favorite flash artist.
Note: I would've typically reviewed this a 10 but I'm much more strict with the "Stars" of Newgrounds. And I do use the term "Star" lightly (No offense)