Reviews for §Zeth§ Forest Theme

[Diabolo-ical]

Overall would be 9.81529581 if it was an option...

I effing LOVE this. It's my favourite of all. I can't find anything to criticize... though I'm in no position to do that since I know so little about orchestral music, despite making it myself, mwhahahaha.

In fact.... *has an idea* YES, I'm going to download my favourites of your music, bung 'em all in a playlist and play Neverwinter Nights. Perfect match. Before I do that though, I'm going to make a poor attempt at making another theme... wish me luck o_0

XGM-Zeth responds:

Thanks Mate!
I wish you luck =)

Well; Thanks for voting and reviewing!
And have fun playing neverwinter nights! :D

-Zeth

[SolusLunes]

Wow.

Edgen has nothing on you, man. This is awesome. I remember playing this game, and this just makes it even better. I just wish I owned it instead of just renting it. The only reason it doesn't get a perfect is because it loops pretty badly. But otherwise, McAwesome.

XGM-Zeth responds:

Edgen still owns me; But I'll get him sooner or later.
Anyways, this song that was (originally) a loop have now turned into a full song, just that it had a crappy ending.

McAwesome! :D
Mmh...burger.

-Zeth

[Khuskan]

Yay!

I havnt heard this one remixed properly yet, and this was a pleasent suprise. It wasnt too bouncy, like many other covers of it are, or too staccato and it had a great feeling to it.

One thing I noticed, was the alto strings on the first part missed a note out of there at the end.

Yours went C# B Bb B Bb B G F# and missed the Ab on the first time round, but not the second, sounded a bit odd considering it was carried with the Ab the rest of the way through.

The other instruements sound great, and are introduced excelently. One problem I did have was either the tuba, or the trobones seemed to sound very parpy after the xylophone. It sounds like it should be taken up an octave to me. Also, turn the volume on that xylophone up. At that point in the song, it holds the melody, but it was being drowned out by the other instruments.

Excelent orchestration though, well done.

XGM-Zeth responds:

Thanks; Constructive Critism is great to have laying around.
As for the string thing; I know.
My brother commented that as well.
And as for the tuba; I turned the velocity a bit too high at the end; making it too dominant; and it should have been up in a higher octave.

the xylophone isnt that dominant at the real thing either; I checked.
But it could have given a touch to the song if i did turn up the volume.

[PiePie]

Hmm

This is good but, the ending was terrible Im sorry to say I was wanting more and getting into it then it just stoped. Very good remix though just not your best work I find and I think you could of done better with this piece.

XGM-Zeth responds:

ouch, that 9 actually stings.
Oh well; Thanks for reviewing.
And the ending wasn't that good in my opinion really either.
But I wanted to be done with this piece.

[spongessuck]

Sweet

I don't remember the forest theme from SMRPG, but regardless, this is a pretty sweet tune. It does sound piraty, too, which is never a bad thing. I do agree it ends suddenly though, even though you probably want it to loop, but maybe you should tag on an ending or maybe just make the end sound like the beginning so it could theoretically loop and not sound strange. Great job though.

XGM-Zeth responds:

Well, It's known as Geno's forest if that helps. Though, the loop part was intentional. I really dont like to create loops.
I might do a second version that in theory will loop.
Thanks.