A little to cartmanish...
The ending was good but the voice acting just sounded like cartman with down syndrom (s/p), i did chuckle once though, and the animation was better then somethings on here, but i just wasnt a big fan of it (even though i do like your other submissions) just put a little more work into the humor and the length of it next time and you'll come to at least a 8 out of 10 with me. Obviously some people must like it though because it made front page.
-vegas
Shivers
I can see how maybe some people find this dark humor entertaining. I gave you some points because the timing of the gruesome event was well done. (Sent a little shiver up my spine.) But the content is not my cup of tea really.
And agreed with the other comment, the voice for the dog doesn't do it for me. It might have been more effective and funny if you spun a more complicated dog character to juxtapose against the punch in the face story line. Keep at it though. All experimentation leads to learning and improvement right? (^_^)
Harsh
I know it's suppost to be funny but I didn't really find it that funny, I thought it was quite sad. The graphics and sound here where good though, I just thought the concept was upsetting :(