Reviews for Broken Saints Chapter 3

[Dullahan]

Very good

I just started watching the series tonight (its about 4:30 am here now, lol). So very, I'm very impressed, I especially love the quotes at the beginning and end of each episode, some I don't know others are my favorites from my favorite philosophers (or however you spell it, sorry if its wrong). Adolf is a fool like many have pointed out and screams of parental fed christianism which should NEVER be used to judge "fairly". You are supposed to have un-biased opinion when writing reviews, and if this is just too much for your brain to comprehend, don't say anything at all until you can write a sound review with good critique. Speaking of which, I love the style this is done in, it's absolutely wonderful for the dark and mysterious atmosphere the series projects. It flows slowly and gives you time to absorb the wonderful background music and to interpret what is said in your own words. Good timing, wonderful artwork (you remind me of my friend Jack, an incredible artist) and so far an intriguing storyline. Now to view the other eleven hours, lol.

[youngone11212]

ay-carumba

this movie was the shizznat (master shake)oh my god the detail was superb the sound the characters the plot. i especially love the quotes at the begining and end they give the film more diversity.overall though keep up the sexy work. i love it.

[poll0u]

nice... clever

well... there are a few things i'd like to say i think are wrong a bout the last review some guy gave to this submission. I think its cool the way the fight is drawn, i think the positions of this characters ARE really expresive and do manage to show how they move and who does what. i think that also the way the character's story is revealed is alright, after all the story is suposed to be mysterious and so on.

[Brae]

A Disconnected Story so Far

Like the previous two chapters, this episode of Broken Saints uses the familiar comic book style, slideshow technique of animation, showing well-drawn pictures accompanied by text to convey thoughts and words. This style gets old quickly; I can generally only sit through one chapter a day.

In this episode, the author takes his familiar animation style and tries, somewhat unsuccessfully, to add a twist: a fight. The fight generally amounts to expressive figures in expressive poses gliding slowly across the screen toward the other figure. It's tough to really imagine what's going on, physically, or who's doing what to who when the picture conveys only this limited visual information, but story-wise, that's not too important, the only thing that matters being who won and why he fought.

Which brings us to story. Plot. This chapter seems completely disconnected from the previous, perhaps telling a different part of the story that won't make sense until later on, when the character featured here, the faithful Muslim, unites his story with those of the other characters. But nothing happens. His story isn't told, so much as hinted at, as all we are shown is this character fighting another, with obtuse, metaphoric language and this character's bizarre experiences briefly shown in the first chapter being all we have to go on when pondering exactly what is taking place and why. The Broken Saints story/saga may be incredibly cool, but you'd have no way of knowing until you've sat through the majority of these long, slow episodes.

[Lemurian]

Wow! O_o

It's amazing... Just when you begin to feel the last chapter you saw was the best of the best, Pow! The hit you in the face with another marvelous artwork. It's amazing, amazing and definitely amazing.