5
This is somewhat passing only because of it's technical proficiency. Other than that I'm a little fuzzy on the reality presented. I confess I watched it without reading your description first and at the end asked myself "why didn't he help everyone?" Then I read the description and saw it was for a religion class and became really confused. I don't even consider myself a religous person, I don't know if there's a god or not, but from I do know, from what I remember being taught, is that no one should be left behind. If the christian incarnation of god is the truth, then he did not put us here to judge, he put us here to love and try to forgive, not just walk on by those we see as "the evil" to help "the good".
As a side note: I'm American, and while I don't consider myself a self depricating one, I will say it was kind of strange to pick a british and apparently indian man to represent war instead of a more immediate example. Maybe you didn't want to make it seem too political to current events? I could understand it if that was your idea.