Reviews for Sin City Tribute

[KidDeath]

Ugh

Ok, so you can draw, good job. The artwork was fantastic, I'll give you that. As for the concepts... it lacked a lot. Anyone can take lines from a popular movie, stick the characters who said them next to it, and basically shorten a good movie in to a couple minutes of pointless ramblings. There was no real story line here, not even the one of Sin City. Random lines from the movie, and the names of Characters. And, when Nancy was a little girl, the villian wasn't Yellow until after he got his nuts shot off, and was rebuilt. Nice try, but hitting things at the hight of their popularity is not something I look for in a flash. Numa Numa was good for about a minute, the WAAAZUP thing had its fame, and everyone hit on thodr... but it doesnt make the work good. But like I said, you kick ass at drawing! I dont have any skill there so I guess I have no real room to critique your work.

[sniper-wolf3]

ok but not enough action!

bad music seioslly was that britney spears or some stupid shit like that!also needs more blood becase its sin city, but i know its youre first so i cut you some slack.

[Dark-FireDragon]

good job!

-TO THOSE WHO SAY IT'S SCRATCHY AND POORLY DONE IT'S SUPPOSED TO BE THAT'S HOW SIN CITY WAS U FUCKING MORONS GO WATCH THE FUCKING MOVIE OR DON'T WATCH THIS FOR PEAT SAKE I MEAN COME ON, U CAN'T MAKE AN EXTREMLY GOOD MOVIE WITH IT BEING SCRATCHY...........

-on another note good job!

[JimmyFatweb]

Sorry

I'm a huge fan of Frank Miller, not just the movie, but i have the comics also. And i must say, most of those images were taken from the comic directly, like copied from some where or scanned, and then edited by you for a few animations like blinking and eyes moving. Not saying it was bad, but dont copy and say you drew it. There were some pics in there that were clearly drawn by you, but not all. Sorry.... you get a 4 for the lack of credit towards wehre the pics came from.

[EDB2]

Draw it yourself next time

The only reason you are getting praise, at all, is because it was a nice tribute. But really, all you did was take images from the comic books and animate them slightly and you made a music video out of that. The music was nice, an old favorite of mine, and you threw in a lot of nice exciting dialogue and memorable scenes from the books that are in the movie. But that means nothing really. Anyone could have done this.

So the low score is for the fact that all you did was steal others work for this tribute. You say it took you days to make it but that doesnt prove you worked hard. The little animation in this flash show everyone how little effort was put in.

With that said, it's still a nice tribute.