Reviews for Sin City Tribute

[Rabidmonkey987]

Movie shows how you can trace comic frames

What's the point of this movie? The music does't fit, the story isn't a story but merely a trailer, and all the visuals have been straight up traced from pannels in the Sin City comics. No originality or real work went into this aside from the base-level gruntwork of tracing over someone else's work. It's also terribly sad to see how you've misled people and have actually gotten praise for being 'honest' because you made it clear this was a 'tribute' to Sin City, when in fact you've mislead people by leaving out the important fact that all you've done is made a compilationo of other people's work (both on the sound and visual sides). Pathetic...

[obiwankenoli]

sin city is awesome

sin city is an awesome series and an awseome movie you did a really good job with this tribute and especially good considering this is your first congrats

[vwab]

Meh

I am an avid Sin City fan and I am sorry to say, this flash really does it no justice. The first frames with Marv, my immediate thought was, "Why is Marv's face gray?" The movie and comics strongly emphasize contrast and so that image seemed very wrong to me. The low scores for graphics and style are due to the fact that the style and majority of these images are the creation of Frank Miller, not you. Therefore you do not really deserve the credit for them. I give sound a 6 only because I like the Cranberries, but the song did not go along with what the movie is about or the theme or anything. It made no sense in the context. I understand you're just a fan making a tribute, but I feel this really does the movie and comics no justice.

[Preceptional]

Bravisimo!

Low Point- The cranberry's career after that album
High Point- Zombie as the theme music for a fantastic Sin City Tribute

Overall- Well done all the way around. The way ALL flash tributes should be done.

[zalgadis]

cranberries soundtrack for sin city

are you kidding me??? cranberries... for a tribute to sin city??? holy hell... yeah it's a tribute, so nothing is innovative and what not, but the cranberries???!!! the CRANBERRIES???!!!!!!! christ on a crucifix cracker... i mean, why not put pulp fiction to britney spears? or the phantom of the opera to "Save a Horse, Ride a Cowboy"???!!!! i'm going off to shed a tear for sin city.