00:00
00:00
Newgrounds Background Image Theme

Heln966 just joined the crew!

We need you on the team, too.

Support Newgrounds and get tons of perks for just $2.99!

Create a Free Account and then..

Become a Supporter!

Reviews for "-Troy-"

HOLD ON THERE.......

OK dude while i was waiting for your flash to load i happened to read all the reviews this piece got and i said to myself "man this cant be as bad as they all say" and i must say while it wasnt i was still very disappointed. im a huge fan of the trojan war and all greek myths and for me your flash just left out too much important stuff. the whole movie just moved by so fast that i could hardly read the subtitles or even tell what was going on o and by the way WHERE WAS ALL THE SOUNDS!!!!!! it really needed music and voice in it. i did like how u did the battles even though i think u just copied the movie troy....keep trying.

A bit...boring

I found it boring and almost a chore to finish watching (which I did before voting, becuase that's only fair). It needs some background music or sounds, rather than just the sound effects of the fighting and such.

meh....

it was ok i guess... needs better music...

Whoa... wait a sec...

Who the hell was troy and what kind of propulsion was on those boats!? I mean dude, it flew for being powered by a sail, mustve been chinese gunpodwer rockets or something. Also, negative points on the same characters fighting each other, it was like watching a bad episode of Star Wars: The Clone Wars. I couldn't tell which side was which. Props on the little battle scene though, I can tell you've got some talent hidden in you. You just need to apply yourself a little more.

Okay... here's what's wrong with it...

You do know that the Trojan War is only a part of history because of the Iliad right... the Iliad by Homer is the oldest piece of literature to originate from Western culture. According to most historians, if the Trojan War had actually taken place, it was likely caused by the theft of livestock rather than someone's wife--Helen. The problem with your movie is that it seems to be more based off of the terrible movie that came out last year of the same name than the Iliad and the Inniad, which is where the story (in all its forms) originated. The story is so tied to characters like Helen, Paris, Hector, Clytemnestra and Achilles is so tied to Greek myth (given that Helen and Achilles are half-mortal descendants of the gods) that to exclude mythological figures in any retelling of the Trojan War would be like making up your own story about it. You say this was for a history class? Did your teacher point out any of these glaring details to you--that the Trojan War probably didn't even happen, that all the little details that you included like the Trojan Horse are not historical facts, but originate from myth, or that there is no historical, archeological or anthropological evidence that the War had actually taken place, rather all that we know about the War stems from Homer's writings? If he/she didn't, then I would call his/her credentials into question. However, if you were presenting on ancient myth for your history class (something usually reserved for the Language Arts departments), then you did a poor job there too. You made no mention of the Greek Gods, the role the played in the fighting, or the sick fascination with death that consumed them as they took sides during the conflict. The only character from myth that you included was Helen--and very briefly at that. This was neither a lesson in myth nor a history lesson. You negate its historical relevance by presenting on something with a questionable--to say the least--historical context. You didn't even mention the origin of the story or the author who wrote it. You negate its mythological value by leaving out essential characters like say the entire Pantheon of Greek Gods. Essentially all you did was rehash the movie Troy into a subpar and boring flash flick. It's good to see that you were trying to be original, but next time, do some research. Also, you can't "get" death as you put it in your movie... death is something that befalls you not something tangible that can be received (sorry that bothered me). Also, your button about Theseus doesn't work. Better luck next time.