fair
the problem i have with xin is the constant overdramatic voice acting and corny dialogue, without that element of humour to let you get away with it. the same music choice but with a more subtle (more natural) tone in their voices would have been enough to convey the sombre mood, that i think you're going for here. else it sounds really overplayed.
but i think the story and the characters been developed well, and the graphic are pretty good.