Tres Magnifique
Here's my score:
Instrument Blend--- 1/1
Accuracy--------------- 1/1
Clear Concept ------- 1/1
Originality------------- 3/3
Appeal----------------- 4/4
Total------------------- 10/10
Instrument Blend:
I loved that you kept the piano for the background harmony and rocked out the melody. It sounded great together.
Accuracy:
Melody Captured. Period.
Clear Concept:
Very well thought out. Not a point in the song where I wondered where you were going with this.
Originality:
When the piano started, I thought "not another copy rendition." And then my jaw dropped. This almost had a "Gackt" feeling to it, and it was very different from any of the other mixed versions of this song.
Other Comments:
This song is really easy to mix softly and really hard to mix with an edge; your rendition deserves tremendous amounts of respect for not taking it overboard, but not leaving the listener with a feeling of deja vu.