Reviews for Making Flash History

[Preternatural]

Biased until the very end.

You got it all wrong man. Way wrong. You obviously haven't taken in consideration some facts when you released this biased top 20 movie.

1)You left behind most of the ones that needed the most work.
2)You included some games in that top 20.
3)You threw in some of the latest releases. As if NO ONE would notice that you are indeed, a newbie.
4)Humor over quality? (-knox-, Decline of Video Gaming, etc.)
5)Graphics over feelings? (
6)Krinkels has two nominations? Biased.
7)True, sprite movies deserve attention, but only when they necessitate more than a full night of work. (referring to 8-bit theater)
8)A tutorial!?!? If you put that in there, it must've been for a really, really good reason, otherwise... it's not even a movie.

Fallen Angel: no1. On a further note, Moonlight kicks major ass. At least top 5 for that one, pal. You also missed that other screwed up Final Fantasy flash.. what's it called again?

No, it's not a matter of taste: it's a matter or worth.

scubakidd responds:

very fair points but I did not put two Madness things in cas i was biased, i just wanted to highlight how they have improved. Just like bunnykill. Ur right bout moonlight though there are just too many great flashes! lol cheers for da comment

[MaskOfIcarus]

Too Focused On The Present

Your movie did highlight some good movies and games but the large problem was that it did little to feature the truly classic games and movies on newgrounds such as "balthors tales from hell" and AYB. These gems should not be left out of a list of the best NG has to offer.

It truly seems to me that you just picked a bunch of movies off of the all time scoring list. However, many good films do not stand to last long on there because many people only vote on movies on the front page. This jumps them up the list replacing much more deserving stuff.

By the way your list sounds, it was based on best fbf action and not humor. If that was what you wanted than maybe you should have said so.

Put much more consideration into this next time.

More films that need to be considered....

Bob the Ball
Balthors Tales From Hell
Dads Home
Menya zovut Shnur
All your base
Work it
Mario Twins (official)
Banana Phone
One Ring to Rule ThemAll2
FF Tribute - Chocobo Mix

Check Em Out if you have not seen them!

scubakidd responds:

Yea, it woz kinda meant to be that sorta thing, things like madness are just so well known that they are put in, alien hominid has recently become a console game so it therefore was put on, but i understand your point and i appreciate your comment very much

[XwaynecoltX]

((( OK )))

It was ok, kinda like a history of some past flash, you should expand it and cover even older stuff then you have, you seem to only have some recent stuff, notbad though nice idea...

~X~

scubakidd responds:

good idea m8, i will update it if the flash manages to stay on Newgrounds 4 a while

[LookingTwiceKills]

NICE WORK!

thats the first time ive ever seen a tribute like that before its very good how u put it all together and quite good for your first submission!
plus anything with greendays music gets an extra point from me!
i gave u a 5 but i ment to give u a 4...lol

good work!

scubakidd responds:

lol cheers 4 da review m8

[Opium-Fields-Forever]

3/5

Nice idea, it'd be cool to see a new version of this maybe once a year or after a long stretch of classics being released. Can't say I agree with half of the ones mentioned. The fucking Bunny Kill series over Salad Fingers? And no Arfenhouse? The real shocker was your failure to mention AYB. Oh, and Walk-Smash-Walk doesn't deserve a place in the top 20 under any circumstances.

scubakidd responds:

I really appreciate your views but I have to take into account what the majority of people thought, but I honestly appreciate you views, cheers