Very moving...
Great song...It really catches the loneliness within anyone that hears it :'(
Reviews for "[MvS}(2)Frozen Alone"
...
Overall I like both of the compositions - you both (rightly, I think) wrote softer, slower pieces that express that lack of movement and activity in the image. I like the higher chime-like sounds in "Alone in Ice" that really express the crystalline, fragile nature of the environment.
My one small criticism would be that I'm not sure that using counterpoint around 2:36 is very effective. The lonely spirit is alone, so having two melodies working together does not seem appropriate.
Great job overall, though.
PGegen
hmmm
sorry Mandi but this one goes to Maestro. His piece just seemed to fit so. . . right. idk but that's just the way it is lol 10/10 5/5
YAYAYAY selcuk wins
well i just think that selcuk got the cavyness of ice thing down well with the chimes and also captured the use of the lead instrument better(sorry Mandi lol) althouhg i think that if Mandi had used lower notes in some spots on maybe...the ..............hmmmm well i think that the ...lute would have actually been great(or the mandolin) but i dont know if u had these in ur free soundfont things so lol (love mediavl instrument go lute!!!)
Reminds me of a game...
Secluk's part with the bassoon reminds me of a game that I cant bring to mind, but his half reminds me more of a lonely gray island where there is constant, depressing rainfall. Mandi's half captures the more fragile, crystalline environment of an ice cavern, so I would have to agree with PGegen and say the victor is Mandi. ( I love all of your music though.)
MaestroRage responds:
That's perfectly alright! Thanks for your vote and the review! Glad you liked it!