Very good work Nate Johnson
I've been following this series for a while now, and it has to be one of the best non-sprite Super Mario (or Toad in this case) flashes I've ever seen. You've gotten much better since the first one, and I like how you brought Toad's neglect into the spotlight (he never gets a main role in any of the Mario games, he's always gets pushed to the side).
The graphics and action were very good, and the music was nicely chosen. Like some of the others said, some voices would bring extra life to the movies, but I know it can be hard finding the right voice.
Congratulations for getting onto the Front Page, and getting the Daily Feature Award, I'm excited about the next episode. As for my vote on who should die next (unless your going with the Nemetoad story instead of taking fan requests), I'd vote for Peach to die. I know she's already died once, but it wasn't really a fight, and Toad must have gotten sick of being her servant for all those years. In most of the games Toad's in, he's just there to protect Peach, which he often fails to do.
One thing I didn't understand was why were Mario and Luigi alive again? Toad had killed them both (Mario 2, 3 times if you count the second Life Mushroom). In any case I'm voting for Peach to die, she's annoying, and should get killed in a proper fight (you've already killed most of the main characters, it's hard who else to vote for).
Great work Nate, I can't wait for the next one. :)