The best.
This is definitely my favourite episode of Salad Fingers. The leap of weirdness from episode 1 to episode 2 is incredible and something I'll never forget as I watched them all in order. I don't believe it is the creepiest - the sadistic qualities of the "boy" in episode 4, and the sheer unadulterated fright you experience when he freaks out in episode 5 beat it for me.
But this is great, as it's where we first really get introduced to SF's lunacy.. the fact that his "friends" are little finger puppets with wonderfully demure little names is probably one of the first things that makes us stare and think "...Umm...Ok.. he's flipped." Rusty spoons notwithstanding!
I gotta say I always chuckle when he hits Hubert Cumberdale with a rusty spoon...
Salad Fingers HAS to be a good series. I lost some respect for the author on seeing the other more macabre pieces, but coming back to Salad Fingers makes me realise this is a great piece in its own right and deserves to be reviewed by itself.