Amazing!
This is truely an amazing song. I've listend to at least over half of your songs. And I must say that this song is in my top 5 favorites from you. It is the perfect song to be your 100th. This song shows just how much work you've really put in. Well done on all of your pieces and I can't wait for more.
Thank you Cap'n!
Nice!
Well, haha there's a lot of bitching going on down there.
Anyways, I read the entire Karco rant, and this song did sound pretty original, he did have some points about the clipping, and the synths.
The mixing was overall good, like I mentioned your synths sometimes feel a little 8-bitty and though I'm in love with 8-bit and oldschool, it sounds off with the high quality piano going on.
At some parts it got a little repetitive but the simple yet interesting variations you kept throwing in there were pretty cool.
Congrats on you 100th submission! You can tell a lot of work went into this
9/10
5/5
-M
Eh.. Thanks for the input. I remastered the mix so it isn't nearly as loud.
Thanks again,
Nate
This is GREAT!
Not my favorite song from you but yet very very good. 5/5 10/10
this was good
Sup Nate,
I think Karco had some good points and criticism never hurt anyone. If anything it may help with some editing of the piece. I'd keep critics close so you're not surrounded by YES men. It'll be hard to push yourself if you have no one pointing out areas of improvement.
I for one, prefer your harder club style songs, and do think this songs structure is lacking a little bit. But there are so many positives about this piece that it stands above the typical submissions here on Newgrounds. I think, revisit this a couple more times and it should place very well in the competition.
Good submission. Keep me posted on your house / club music, and let me know if you revisit this piece.
RR
voted 5 because i'm fighting for the cause against regulator (0) voters.
Like I said below though, I'm always open for criticism. But he said some other things I don't appreciate. I dunno RR, but it's just how I am I guess.
Where's the maturity level?
First of all, someone who registers a new account just to tell someone to shut up has a little too much time on their hands. I mean, seriously. Its because of people like JDMFSeanP (don't know what that means, but whatever) that are driving all the good artists away from posting stuff. They might sound boring, but they're being honest and if we can't respect their criticism we might as well not complain. Some of us are just too big of a fan to hear smart people criticise. And Karco is not a moron. Listen to him criticize a song you hate, and when you agree with him listen to some of his stuff. It's worth it.
Sorry for that blurb! Anyway, this song doesn't sound as unoriginal as it does to a trained ear, but it's not my style. The piano sounds nice for the most part, but the song as a whole sounds a little too cluttered and loud. You have a good melody as usual, but I'd much rather to a more laid-back style of trance. I commend you on 150 songs and good luck on placing in the MAC.
I think I'll go listen to some music by Karco now.
FF~
Heh, thank you for your kind words. Me and Karco talked through the PM inbox and we're all good now.