Reviews for Mutant City

[Violet-AIM]

excellent

Great idea and flash movie. But I am a bit disappointed that you (MarkMcPherson) decided to have someone else make the flash for you. It didn't look like it was something you couldn't do (if u did the storyboards, u can do the movie). It kind of shows lack of confidence in yourself, as an artist/animator. You're an A+ author with a high batting average and you got 22 awards, and you still have doubts about yourself? About ppl criticizing you for your artwork before, don't listen to them. Ppl will always complain about something, so don't take it too personally. If anything, they're just jealous how well you've done with yourself at NG. I hope you get back to drawing/animating on your own two feet, like you did before, cause I have more respect for authors that do. And if you're talking about improving your art, how is it going to get better(not that it has to) by having someone else do it for you. Well you do what you like, just have more confidence in yourself, you're doing just fine. :)

Sipho1312 responds:

i understand what you're saying but one thing that i respect McPherson for is that we share a similar situation, the whole work/school thing. And it will keep you so busy that often you have free little time. I offered to help McPherson with this. He didnt ask me. So if anything, it's my fault. I just wanted to be apart of it.In no way is McPherson losing any confidence..He's just giving a newbie animator like myself a chance...I appreciate your review and the score you gave us. Thank you

[IamBetterThanYou]

nice

it is a great peice of flash work, its refreshing to see a flash with a good story...nice work
i love the art too, its all good.

i hope 2 see the next part of this soon....have you thought of adding voices to the characters..that would be sweet.

[JEKKKAAA]

that was ok

that was ok the art work was pretty good the animaton wasnt so clever tho it has quite a good story line. but needs to be explained in depth.

[BlackSwordDragon]

McPherson Rules!

My friends and I are big fans of the Necromancer series and are interested in seeing what Mutant City is all about. With a new artist helping you we expect great things.

[n0ir]

worst animation EVER!!!

WTF man!? Youre drawing show that you could do so much better!! Moving mouths... walking feet... less motion tweens and more frame by frame..

The animation just didnt run smooth at all.. the sound was descent, some noises were very very very annoying. (the twomouthed monster).. and this thing was made by 2 people which is even worse.. It should have been a much better effort.. The story line was descent, too much like X-men, but people copy plots all the time..

I'm giving you a 3 because it had a descent plot, and descent graphics.. but i no markmcphersons stuff and it has great story lines, but you guys Fucked up on this one..
i miss coment magnum tho! thats the greatest shit on NG, but this thing isnt too great...

Sipho1312 responds:

well if you took the time to read the whole info, you would have seen that it was a bit rushed and that i promised a much better second episode