Reviews for Cello Concerto no. 1 1st mvnt

[Fisherdec]

it was alright

I thought it was kinda interesting but still not exactly my kind of concerto, although I thought your cadenza was somewhat interesting. But still it sounded still to cinematic in my opinion adding a little to much of the cheese factor in my opinion. I guess it would be a nice childrens concerto so in that respect I would have to hand it to you. Please don't find me over critical because I can tell you worked very hard on this so I will congratulate you. good work and keep on writing.

MusicalRocky responds:

I think it's not so much cinematic-sounding as perhaps 20th century/romantic. It's definitely not classical, I can see that. But it's definitely not cinematic. It's also not "a children's concerto," as you said. I'm not even sure what you meant by this. Why would anyone write a concerto for children? The style isn't childlike either; it's rather mature. I'm just confused here. Did you listen to the concerto in its entirety? All three movements? It's a full work, so take that into account. Listening to just this movement will definitely affect your view on the work.

Anyway, though I don't see you as being overly critical, your score of 5/10 didn't really suit your level of criticism. Think of it as a test. A 50%. Severely failing, in your opinion? I don't see that.

Thanks for the review,

Rocky

[SkullZero1]

My hats off to you

Beautiful composition!

MusicalRocky responds:

thank you sir!

-Rocky

[adompeace]

Yo!

That was really tight, man! Really well composed. How long did this take you? We should compose something together sometime! I play all genres of piano (usually classical).

XGEN0CID3, if you don't like classical, then why would you click on something that says "Cello Concerto No. 1?" Even you should know what's coming, idiot.

Don't listen to him, his mind is too feeble to understand classical music.

MusicalRocky responds:

Hey!
Glad you liked it. This movement took me maybe 2 months. Yeah, it takes a long time. :) Yeah we should collab sometimes, definitely!

I'm not worried about XGEN0CID3 really. There's sadly always someone who doesn't like Classical, and yeah he should've known, but oh well.

I'm glad you liked it, again. Thanks for the review.

-Rocky

[thefev]

Great

Who wrote this song?
and to the last review: if you don't like classical music, don't listen to it. I mean it's not something that a small brain can handle, ok? So just leave it be.

MusicalRocky responds:

I wrote this song :)

Haha thanks for busting up on that guy too. He shouldn't even have reviewed. And if he doesn't like Classical, why click on a song that says "Cello Concerto no. 1 1st mvnt"?

But anyway, thanks for the review,

Rocky

[XGEN0CID3]

Zz...

freekin nap time music my god...

MusicalRocky responds:

lolol
you're hilarious.

thanks,

Rocky