ok....

but it was slow

not bad for a first

nice flash animation, but i see no sense in there. a story and a little faster and you'll make it to the top ^^

meh

It was alright but it could've been way better like or story or something. Sonic and shadow would't just fight for no reason

nice battle

it was a good animation, but a litle slow. but overall i think it was good

erm...

why did sonic and shadow fight?
the animation were good, but your flash has no story, and flashmovies without stories won't be rated well, especially if they are very short.
but I'm sure, your next flash will be better.