Gah! Being the only reviewing in here right now is killing a lot of time i need having exams coming up... : P
At 5/15/05 01:45 PM, Mast3rMind wrote:
Here is one of my most strongest and most realsitic stories that I've ever made. Gangs are still a problem in the U.S. this story ties closly to fabric of gang life.
No Regrets
So here it is, short and sweet.
1) Edit: Typos and awkward sentences. Grammar was pretty good ithink, maybe a splice or two, but iwasn't looking for those.
2) Dialogue is key! You told so much, you forgot to show.
3) Some great gems, but some aweful downfalls. Try not to sound like that 11 year old kid telling his story... sound like the adult how ever man years later. Sometimes you write some amazing lines, and the sometimes you write something too quickly, unprecise, and blandly. Read it aloud and try to execute some of those pedestrian-like lines. You just need balance is all ,which comes with practice, i assure.
4) Keep using imagery. The few images you used, you used well! Keep showing, and try telling less, because you can do it well, you just need to do it more often.
5) Be desciptive, you ran through his whole life a little quick. And they fell in love pretty wuick. I like how you introduced that Maria was his love before you described that night togethor, but describe the acts and convo that took place to make it more original and less cliche. : )
Overall, nice job. It was good, but just not balanced. Some amazing parts, some horrible. So the amazing parts show me you have it in you, you just need consistency. Hope this helps.
At 5/15/05 01:57 PM, -TheDoctor- wrote:
Yeah, I'm really not too good at that when writing a fictional narrative. Most of the work-related stuff I have written is very much formal, thus requiring little use of "dynamic" paragraphing (As I like to call it). I'll see if I can work on it, but don't expect too much improvement.
Heh, okay. It is just very effective and quite important, i think. Just whenever anyone new talks... new paragraph, new topic = new paragraph... thats the basics... anything beyond that is style and can only be used effectively by practicing and seeing what works for your writing.
The change wasn't really meant to be smooth, due to their line of work, the characters in that section had to have a very casual approach ("Shit happens"). On the other hand, no one in that kind of a situation could reall be "ok" with what they were doing, thus when Carter mocked Watson's philosophy he just got pissed (the new guy thinking he knows it all, when actually he doesn't have a clue). Plus doing what they are, none of these people are likely to have immaculate mental health, so mood swings are abundant ;)
Ahh, i get what you mean now. However, that wasn;t evident to me when i read it. So maybe you should infultrate that somehow. Because chacracter is character and each is indivual and you don't want mix ups b ythe reader, considering you like to use long dialogues as well (which i like btw).
Thanks again, I'll try and have the next installment ready by tomorrow.
Sounds good!
At 5/16/05 06:20 AM, _IAMCanadian_ wrote:
Glad to see you. : )
MOSH
Sry, i probably won't be able to relate, but for style.. i will review.
Stanza 1
Ahh, man... good writing, but the rhyme couplet would have been key there. Iwas so feeling it, and the ending thre me off. : P Stil lgood though.
Stanza 2
Ahh, now that is better. Nice closing to the stanza!
Thousands become one, the heartbeat synchronized in every chest
I move with the sea, fighting the current
Contradictory? Metaphor to confusion i hope, or else, makes no sense.
Disoriented, faces swirling through my vision
A jewel in the darkness captures my eye
Jewel? Hmm, i guess i'd have to be there to know? I have never experienced a mosh pit.
Stanza 4
'Pocket' is a good word, it works really well for some reason. Sometimes the simple things make a world of difference.
Stanza 5
The last line was awkward.
Stanza 6
Confusing...
Stanza 7 (Final)
Ahh, nice closing. It kind of saves the last stanza which lost me in sense, but had me in imagery.
Good job, it is well done for a first poem. I am sure it would have been more effective if i could have related, but as to structure and style... it was loose, but well done. Imagery is strong.
At 5/16/05 02:44 PM, -Manman- wrote:
Okay I should take a snother stab at something that can be taken a little more seriously than my last couple of works. But c'mon, they were awesome.
Um, a little concedced? lol They were awsomely disturbing, but none the less decent pieces.
The painted rabbit
Stanza 1
Rhyme = flows.
Stanza 2
I read on, becuz i mintrgued, but have yet to make sense of it. Meter flows as well, though its free.
Stanza 3
Ahh, a song? Chorus? Will read on. If its not a song, then its cheesy, becuz it needs music to support the repedativeness.
Stanza 4
Weakest stanza thus...
Stanza 5
I really like, but you really killed the rhyme and meter : P Which has it lose flow; however, it seems to be a song, which makes it an amazing hook, but if poetry... its awkward.
Stanza 6
Yay, song it must be. : )
It was good, if it was a song. Otherwise, it was all over the place. Overall, great work, but deffiently better as a ballad, than as poetry itself to be read alone.
Great job! Oh, and i like the slight change in chorus. Variety = more interesting.
At 5/16/05 06:38 PM, -repent- wrote:
Het Myst do you ever do like an acrostic poem or a rant? My teacher say it is poetry, but I do not see anything that resembles a poem.
I am not a fan of Acrostic poems... they suck lol:
Stupid little poems
Unused for meaningful purpose
Carefully unwitful
Kindly give me a headache
Wow that sucked... see what i mean?
And about Rants... i have no idea... but if you man free verse about prersonal issues, i do it all the time.
I promise that I will come up with something during the summer maybe a couple of short stories.
I can't wait!