There was a game I remember playing on newgrounds, but I can't find it since I don't remember the name of it.
The game was a pixel platformer, where you were a lumberjack and you and your buddies were cutting down trees and placing the wood on an alter (I think there was some sort of time limit). When night came, they went into their houses and slept. You could kill them if you wanted. If you did some looking around, you could find an evil looking cave where you had the ability to resurrect your dead buddies as zombies. At the end of the game, depending on whether or not your actions were evil and/or if you successfully got enough wood for the sacrifice, a giant being will appear in the background and the game will end.
There may have also been medals for the game (that might have been how I found it in the first place).