Good Music
Ok. I'll go first...
The Pros: The best part of the song is the melodies and harmonies used. Nothing is out of tune and it conveys the story successfully. The arrangement is also satisfying bringing nice highs and lows to the table.
That being said I don't have any problems with those part and I think this is a nice piece of emotional music.
The Cons: it's the sound I'm having problems with. To be exact it's the contrasting quality of the beautifully sounding piano with the awfully sounding sampled guitarwork and bad frequencies on the drumset (almost no kick and the hihats hurt a little) + although the filter sweep bringing the song in it's heavy part works very well, the resonance should be lowered to avoid ear pain.
Overall: It's a good piece of solid musicianship that could use a bit better mixing. Because of the sound I thus rate this: 4/5 8/10