Thank you TenodiBoris for supporting NG!

We're 15 people from our target today. Why don't you be one of them?

You can support NG too and get tons of perks for just $2.99.

Create a Free Account and then..

Become a Supporter!

PianO RolL

Share Download this loop

Author Comments

I put some time into this one but you have to listen to the whole thing to hear the ending and how it changes.. or you can just skip[ ahead... at 00:53 thats where it changes, the beat drop and well just listen to it .. what evers clever


Okay I'll rev. this one

Hmm, interesting song. It's different from the usual type of techno on NG. Here are my comments.

1) I like that instrument (not sure if two instruments are playing) right at the beginning of the song. Very happy sounding. Plays a fun beat too.
2) 1:35 I like the crystallized piano. Only last for a brief moment. Why? That was the best part.

Not sure:
1) 13 seconds in and this very quiet piano comes in. Make it louder maybe? I can hardly hear it. The piano beat is also a bit off key when it plays with that happy techno instrument.
2) So I think you need a background sound because the song feels empty. Maybe add a heaven like instrument with lots of sustain. You could implement that nice piano at 1:35 more into the song too.

A short song so not much to talk about thus a short review from me. I think you should expand on this song. Put some more reverb on your instruments and include a background instrument....now you got a much better song. Also longer song with new instruments later introduced. That's all I got to say. 5/5 vote and 9/10 review.
Bye for now

People find this review helpful!
cartoon781 responds:

Thanks ALOT for all the compliments and pointers on how to make it better. But I cant find my melody file so i cant fix it. I looked everywhere. Im going to try and make it over but first Im going to keep looking for it. As soon as i get it done ill let you know.

It's an alright start...

There's some nice ideas, especially the groovy part around 1:15 where you have that one instrument start to echo or something against the chords. The synth chords are a bit too loud, and it's kind of hard to hear the other instrument. The mix sounds a bit barren though with just the two instruments you have, both of which occupy about the same range (lower treble). I'd think about adding some more instruments, at least a bass line so we can get some of the lower register filled. The build-up part near the end felt kind of unnecessary since it's winding to close but the increase in volume made it sound like it was actually going somewhere else. Maybe change up the chords some too once since they pretty much don't change from start to finish.

Anyways, right now it sounds rather mediocre, but if you continue to work on this it might turn into something nice.


This is neat, you should have however used somthing a little less harsh in the beginning. it would go much better with the tiny blips in the background, also you should use a course or soft filter on the 3rd synth to come in, but i lite the idea,

6/10 5/5

I'm impressed

You did that entire track in piano roll? Kudos to you.

cartoon781 responds:


Click on an icon to vote on this!

Credits & Info


3.63 / 5.00

Mar 4, 2008
8:56 PM EST
File Info
1.6 MB
1 min 45 sec

Licensing Terms

Please contact me if you would like to use this in a project. We can discuss the details.