this totally deserved 2nd place, amazing job!
lol barely made it in time!
One of the rare occasions where I pick up the guitar to make music. I think I should do it more often.
It was very fun to create this song. Tried out cool effects such as ValhallaFreqEcho. This song gives me such vibes of nature and going outside and the culmination just makes it feel like you are flying.
This song kinda reminds me of a song I made years ago called Holding on to the Clouds
Oh! Also a really cool thing I played around was the time signatures. I think I had like 7/8 6/8 and 4/4
Stuff I used for the cloud reverie was a couple of serums, Addictive keys, FL Studio FPC drums - HQ Jazz kit, 2 different classical guitars. Splice sample library (blips, impacts, drum ride, crash, clap, bells or something, birds, rain)
For the effect plugins I used - OTT on the master ;) , Ozone 9 elements, kHs bitcrush, SPAN, ValhallaSupermassive, ValhallaFreqEcho, kHs compressor, iZotope Trash 2, ValhallaSpaceModulator, panners, gains, fruity eq lol
Here is how the project looks like.
this totally deserved 2nd place, amazing job!
Thank you so much!! :D
I disagree that this doesn't suit a flying track, if by flying you mean on a bullet train through various fields. That's the feeling this evokes for me. In addition to the comments of SplatterDash and TL, I think this track is a bit mid heavy, but there is not much else wrong with it. Perhaps it could actually use less dynamic range, in my opinion. I enjoyed it!
This is an NGADM 2023 judge review.
I think you know as much as I understand that this song was a massive risk in its concept alone, and I think a majority of it paid off well. The unusual sound design helped to give a unique atmosphere - not necessarily one that I think fit your idea of flying or nature, but something that was ethereal and interesting to listen to. The composition was interesting, with its start in 6/8, going to 4/4, and then back to 6/8, to the point where it felt seamless and hard to distinguish when those changes happened.
As for the general production and sound design, I felt the production was good, but it was held back when the introduction of the synthesized sounds occur. I think that transition is good compositionally, but can use some help from the production area. Speaking of which, while your sound design was a huge risk, the only problem I heard was that the synthesized elements could be balanced in terms of mixing with the acoustic elements. It felt like what was synthesized was taking over the acoustic, which didn't help too much in elevating your idea.
Overall, I think your risks paid off! You went with something outside the box, and I think it mostly worked and was pretty unique.
Thank you so much :D Yeah! I did a lot of experimenting. Didn't really give a second thought while making this, because I let my intuition do all the work on this one xD
I like the tranquil guitar and nature sound effects at the beginning. The tempo feels very loose towards the beginning, and the panning is a little too heavy for my tastes. The sound design is really good, including the glitchy electronic elements that really bleed into the texture by 1:04. Sounds like an edgier version of “Every Photon, 100 Times a Second” by @SleepFacingWest. The melodic content in this piece is also good, but a bit understated at times, like the smooth synth melody at 1:50. I also think the arrangement is a tad choppy, with some sudden transitions and a compositional approach that’s taking you in a few different directions at once. The atmosphere, instrumentation, and production are probably my favorite elements of the piece, although the experimental texture and rhythmic content are not far behind. Really evocative work, LordAndiso! Keep it up. ^_^
Mixing, mastering, and balance
1.75/2
Structure, transitions, phrasing, and variety
1/1.5
Melody, tonality, harmony, and texture
1.75/2
Instrumentation and sound design
1/1
Emotion, atmosphere, and catchiness
1.5/1.5
Originality and uniqueness
1/1
Overall (how do the elements above interact?)
1/1
Composite score
9/10
Thank you so much for the review! I will learn a lot from this! This is amazing that there are competitions like this, really brings the artists self-improvement :D
never fails to impress 🔥 keep up the work dude youre carrying newgrounds
Thank you soo much :))) I am very happy that you liked it! :D
You may only use this piece for commercial purposes if your work is a web-based game or animation, otherwise you must make specific arrangements with the artist.