Rythym mannn
ARound 3:15 your stuff's good but you shimmy about rythym wise a little bit.
Just a bit. Slow down and then catchup or something.
Maybe it's supposed to be like that. But, if it isn't. Use metronome moar.
Reviews for "the Composer"
nice music, but
half of the music was abura
It has the powers to make stars.....EXPLODE!!!!!
From boredom. It takes too long to reach the good part of this piece. I still think it's good (as in butterscotch). You should revise the beginning and make the orchestra come out sooner. I've seen the Composer, I know how the piece was used in it, so I know what I'm talking about.
Ok, I'll review this...
And a bunch of you will hate me for it. But most what I will say is completely objective, with the exception of the next paragraph.
The song is honestly not that great. Sorry, it's ok, but it's just way overrated. Even jazza obviously didn't think it was very good until all of the musically inept fanboys came along. Nice emotion in the piece, although in the video you seemed to deal a low blow to rock music, which ticks me off, as it's just as much a valid form of music and some pianist, probably even more so.
As for the music, there were quite a few screwups. First thing on the page I see is the there are tempo markings on both staves. At measure 32, there's a notation error, from 36 to 37 there are three straight parallel fifths, which look like crap. From 37 to 38 there is another parallel fifth. There are double tempo markings again. Far too many leger lines on page 2, no one's going to be able to read that. Double notation again, although I like that you used 8/8. And yeat, it's still marked as 4/4. another problem there. A real pianist might see that and play 8/8, but they may also end up putting the emphasis on the wrong notes, so that's an error in my book. Backing up, between 54 and 55, there are two meter markings. So yeah. Fix that, and maybe I'll give it a chance.
Here it is folks, my review,
Piano, happy, the song of a widely known flash in newgrounds. Of course this going to be a high scoring song. I manged to scroll down that long list of reviews and what do you know, I find 1 person who aggrees with me. MJTOMB I believe. The Only person who gave this a score lower than 5. I checked the sheet music too, and would you look at that, filled with errors. I also have to aggree with Marauder-3, it does have the poer to make the stars explode, along with my ears.