I agree with other reviewers that the animation is very good here. You could have easily competed in the "animations with interactive elements" category for the Jam.
Unfortunately the game itself is short, frustrating, and unrewarding. The baseball bat-wielding character is the most overpowered due to reach, but even then the only real strategy is to run away from the fight and let the other players kill each other until you go and fight the last one. This is surprisingly hard because of how quick the AI's response time is.
Not much else to this game, there's no story and the whole thing is over in 10 seconds if that.