Reviews for Strip 'em all

[PoisonHeart]

You know, y'all lost me with the first comic that loads after the redirect. I think you lost half of the people who tried the game for different reasons, one probably being that they were very wary of being redirected to another site without ANY warning.

That being said, you lost me because I didn't understand how I was supposed to re-arrange "The Little Cynic". I tried clicking on the panels, and I tried draggin' them around but all I got was "no, that's not right!".
Pretty clever takes on the Sunday funnies though. I like that this tries to not only express ideas of philosophy, but also teach something about working with art.

out of 10...
gfx - 10
sfx - N/A
ganeplay - 7
design - 9

AthleticDesign responds:

I will add a "warning" that you will be redirected to a new page.

We obviously have to make some changes to The Little Cynic. Way too many people have trouble solving it right away. Thank you for your comments.

[tkdKickChick]

So far, so good. I suggest that you indicate that we need to click on the speaker instead of the speech bubble, that took me a while to figure out. I don't know why the game needs a redirect, why can't we play it all on Newgrounds? I like the style of gameplay, it's unique and truly puzzling. If it had been finished and didn't have the unexplained redirect, then 5 stars, as-is, only 4. Keep up the good work!

AthleticDesign responds:

Thank you! We'll certainly need to stress more that you are supposed to click on objects - significant objects - rather than anywhere on the panel or on text/speech bubbles.

[jasonl816]

The game is good as long as you make new mechanics and more panels to work with. Otherwise, it's a little boring though the facts about the comics you put in is good. It needs music a little though, maybe it's good without it, but somehow something feels....missing.

AthleticDesign responds:

I like it silent as it is and it will most likely stay that way. Thanks for playing.

[Killingyoutwice]

This is a very interesting concept and I would love to see what else could be done with it. I really like the aspect of changing the panels as well as all of the other concepts introduced like continuity. What I would have liked to see more of is complexity. I know this is just a tutorial, but I was really disappointed because of the lack of things to do after the tutorial. I did go on to the other comics on the website and they delivered on the intellectual stimulation that I was craving, but what was published on here pales in comparison to the other comics. If there were one thing I were to ask of you. It is to lengthen the game. Possibly add the comics that are, as of this writing, being linked to the website. Do that, and this game would improve exponentially.

AthleticDesign responds:

The game will certainly be expanded and perhaps we will also change the tutorials. We do not want to lump all comics together in one game file and there are several reasons for this: the comics will vary a lot in size (number of panels) and therefore the swf-dimension will also vary; we do not want one giant (> 20MB) swf-file; we want easy "viral spreading" of each comic separately. It has nothing to do with us trying to redirect traffic from NG. The game is far from complete and we wanted some feedback before continuing - that's why we posted it here.

Thanks a lot for the feedback and I am very happy that you found it intellectually stimulating!

[Milos5111]

Boring...Dong play this when youre tired.